Skip to content

In-game tests

Mechanics the sims assume but nobody has measured in game, largest estimated effect first: a result from any of them corrects the sims.

49 mechanics

  1. 1Maul threat multiplierDruid×1.75 (wowsims)36 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced15 min (45 min with the other three bear tests), solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 druid in Dire Bear Form, top Maul rank, a training dummy or a mob that can't kill you. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
    2. Calibrate: 20 plain white hits with nothing else in the same instant. Threat gained ÷ damage = form multiplier F.
    3. Queue Maul on 20+ swings. Keep only non-crit Mauls with no other event in the same instant (no Enrage, no Primal Fury or other rage gain).
    4. Each Maul: threat gained ÷ (damage × F). Plot threat against damage: a line through zero means no flat part.
    5. Run the Swipe, Primal Bite and Lacerate tests in the same session.
    Sims now
    ×1.75 on Maul's damage. wowsims #822, a hand value: its PR says no game file states it.
    Alternative
    ×1, plain damage threat: our 25 Oct value. No measurement either.
    Sims right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.75.
    Alternative right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.0 (our 25 Oct value). Any other ratio, or a flat part: a new value to model.
    Impact
    ×1.75 vs ×1: bear TPS +30.4..+33.7 % 1 boss · 1 min, +30.7..+36.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine). Maul, Swipe and Primal Bite together at our values: −21.5..−22.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, −35.3..−37.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min TPS.
    Effort
    15 min (45 min with the other three bear tests), solo
  2. 2Swipe threat multiplierDruid×1.75 (wowsims)24 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo (needs 2+ targets)

    How to test

    1. Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test.
    2. Stand at 2-3 mobs or dummies. Swipe 20+ times with auto-attack stopped (a /stopattack macro).
    3. Read threat gained on your current target per Swipe and that target's Swipe damage; non-crits only.
    4. Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F).
    Sims now
    ×1.75 (wowsims #822, a hand value with no source).
    Alternative
    ×1 (our 7 Oct value; the Season of Discovery ×2 was dropped then). No measurement.
    Sims right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.75.
    Alternative right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.0.
    Impact
    ×1.75 vs ×1: bear TPS +17.6..+23.5 % 3 bosses · 1 min; 1 boss · 1 min 0 (no Swipe on one boss) (our engine).
    Effort
    10 min, solo (needs 2+ targets)
  3. 3Do melee swings keep landing while you channel Volley?Hunterswings continue (wowsims)≈18 %Survival melee10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. A hunter with a melee weapon, Volley trained, a training dummy. Turn on /combatlog.
    2. Stand in melee range and start auto attack. Let three or four swings land.
    3. Channel Volley on the dummy for its full 6 s, still in melee range. Don't move or cast anything else.
    4. In the log, count melee swings (SWING_DAMAGE, SWING_MISSED) between Volley's start and its aura fading.
    5. Repeat three times with a slow weapon and three times with a fast one.
    Sims now
    Yes. Only a spell with a cast time holds a melee swing; a channel holds none, so a hunter in melee range keeps swinging through Volley's 6 s (wowsims sim/core/attack.go, sim/hunter/volley.go). Survival (melee) channels Volley from 2 targets: on 3 bosses for 1 min it channels 54 of 60 s, and Volley is 55 % of its damage.
    Alternative
    No: the channel stops or pauses melee swings, as it stops Auto Shot. No measurement either way.
    Sims right if
    Swings land through the channel at the weapon's normal speed (about 6 s ÷ weapon speed each).
    Alternative right if
    No swings during the channel, or one held to its end: melee swings pause while channelling.
    Impact
    Melee swings and Raptor Strike landing during the channels: 17.5 % of Survival (melee)'s damage on 3 bosses · 1 min (one logged fight, 13 Nov; estimated). Survival (melee) is #2 on 3 bosses · 1 min at 1,890; without them about 1,560, sixth. 1 boss · 1 min 0 (no Volley on one boss).
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  4. 4Is the 10 Nov Enhancement hotfix live?Shamannot live (client rows)16 %Enh5-10 min, solo; re-check each week

    How to test

    1. Any shaman with Stormstrike: read its tooltip (weapon damage %, cooldown) and time the cooldown once.
    2. Read the Mental Dexterity and Maelstrom Weapon talent tooltips at each rank.
    3. Windfury Weapon on the main hand and your own Windfury Totem down: hit a dummy 3 min with /combatlog on. Count procs of each (the log names both).
    4. Repeat after each weekly maintenance (next 17 Nov) until the values change.
    Sims now
    Pre-10 Nov values: Stormstrike 150 % weapon damage / 6 s cooldown, Mental Dexterity 50/100/150 % of Intellect as AP, Maelstrom Weapon 20 procs a minute at every rank and 4 % a stack per point, a main-hand Windfury Weapon replaces the party's Windfury Totem. Source: client rows of 12 Nov 06:16 UTC and player reports.
    Alternative
    Blizzard's 10 Nov hotfix list: Stormstrike 100 % / 8 s, Mental Dexterity 33/66/100 %, Maelstrom 20 % a stack at 6/7/8/9/10 procs a minute by rank, Windfury Weapon and Windfury Totem both proc.
    Sims right if
    150 % / 6 s, old talent text, only the weapon's Windfury procs.
    Alternative right if
    100 % / 8 s and the new text: model the block (the 71-line patch is measured). Both Windfury procs seen: drop the imbue-replaces-totem rule.
    Impact
    Stormstrike, Mental Dexterity and Maelstrom together: Enhancement −15.9/−16.2 % 1 boss · 1 min, −12.7/−13.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Pieces on our engine: Stormstrike −9.5..−9.8 %, Mental Dexterity −3.0..−3.1 %, Maelstrom −4.5..−4.6 % 1 boss · 1 min. Weapon + totem: 0 on saved sets (Rockbiter), a new candidate if live.
    Builds
    Enh
    Effort
    5-10 min, solo; re-check each week
  5. 5Lacerate threat multiplier at level 60Druid×10/3 (wowsims)47 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test, top Lacerate rank.
    2. 20+ non-crit Lacerate hits on one target with auto-attack stopped, and 30+ ticks.
    3. Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F), for hits and for ticks separately.
    4. Note the stack count at each hit (the sim counts the stack the hit adds).
    Sims now
    ×10/3 on hit and ticks (wowsims #945 threat log: rank 2 in Bear Form firm, 33/40 hit and 59/65 tick windows; later ranks in Dire Bear fit only in part, 37/80 and 46/74 windows, none at ×1 or ×3).
    Alternative
    ×1 (our 7 Oct value).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 3.33 on hits and ticks at the top rank.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 1.0. Any other value: model it.
    Impact
    ×10/3 vs ×1: bear TPS +42.8..+47.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..+2.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine).
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  6. 6Primal Bite threat multiplierDruid×3 (wowsims)13 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test, top Primal Bite rank.
    2. 20+ non-crit Primal Bites with auto-attack stopped.
    3. Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F); check for a flat part.
    Sims now
    ×3, no flat part (wowsims #822/#945: 'measured on the first two ranks', levels ~37-51, sample not published).
    Alternative
    ×2 (our 7 Oct value, from the 70170 note 'roughly doubled').
    Sims right if
    Ratio ≈ 3.
    Alternative right if
    Ratio ≈ 2.
    Impact
    ×3 vs ×2: bear TPS +12.3..+13.2 % 1 boss · 1 min, +8.4..+9.7 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine).
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  7. 7Chain Lightning overload chance per targetShamanfull chance (ours)13 %Ele20 min, solo (needs 3 targets)

    How to test

    1. Level 60 Elemental shaman, Lightning Overload at max rank, /combatlog on.
    2. One dummy: 100+ Lightning Bolts. Overloads ÷ casts = p.
    3. A group of 3+ mobs or dummies: 60+ Chain Lightnings that hit 3 targets (180+ target hits).
    4. Count overload copies per target hit (the log names the overload spell and its target).
    Sims now
    Full Lightning Overload chance on every target hit (our patch: the 408438 row and tooltip state one chance for both spells). No log.
    Alternative
    A third of the chance per target (wowsims code; its own PRs #821/#839 say no game file states it).
    Sims right if
    Overloads per target hit ≈ p.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ p/3. (180 target hits separate p from p/3 for any p above about 10 %.)
    Impact
    Full vs 1/3: Elemental 3 bosses · 1 min +12.0/+12.5 %, 1 boss · 1 min +0.7 %. Elemental is #1 on 3 bosses · 1 min (1,784); at 1/3 it falls behind Lone Wolf (estimated).
    Builds
    Ele
    Effort
    20 min, solo (needs 3 targets)
  8. 8Revelation enchant: which hits roll itDruidMagePriestShamandamaging hits + channel ticks (wowsims)7.1 %Frost, Balance, Ele, Shadow30 min, solo per class (a mage and a priest)

    How to test

    1. Level 60 mage with Revelation on the weapon, /combatlog on, 3+ dummies or mobs.
    2. Channel Blizzard for 100+ ticks. Count Revelation procs on a tick with no direct cast landing.
    3. Priest (or warlock) with Revelation: 100+ Shadow Word: Pain (or Corruption) casts on fresh targets. Count procs at the application.
    4. The rate (9 vs 8.85 %) needs thousands of hits: skip it.
    Sims now
    wowsims's rules: only landed hits that deal damage or heal, plus each tick a channel casts (Blizzard, Hurricane, totems). Source: the row's Can Proc From Procs flag and the tooltip; no log. Rate 9 % (MythicSim's log count is 8.85 %).
    Alternative
    Our old rules: any landed non-crit spell hit or heal, zero-damage landings included (dot application, channel start), never a channel tick.
    Sims right if
    Procs on ~9 % of Blizzard ticks, none on dot applications.
    Alternative right if
    None on ticks, ~9 % on applications. A mix: model each part as seen.
    Impact
    wowsims's rules vs ours (our engine): Frost 3 bosses · 1 min +7.1/+6.8 %, Balance 3 bosses · 1 min +5.5/+5.9 %, Elemental 3 bosses · 1 min +1.3/+2.1 %, Shadow −2.9 % 1 boss · 1 min, −3.3 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Ticks alone: Frost 3 bosses · 1 min +10.7 %.
    Effort
    30 min, solo per class (a mage and a priest)
  9. 9Holy Strike's spell power sharePaladin≈ 0.21 (wowsims)4.2 %Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat, Prot Pala · Balanced20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 paladin, Holy Strike Rank 8, no Judgement of the Crusader on the target, /combatlog on, a training dummy.
    2. 40+ non-crit Holy Strikes in normal gear; average them.
    3. Add about +100 spell power (an elixir or an item), nothing else; 40+ more.
    4. Rise in the average ÷ spell power added = the share.
    Sims now
    Spell power through the weapon percent: 0.429 × 50 % ≈ 0.21 at Rank 8 (wowsims, by analogy with the Seal of Command proc; no log).
    Alternative
    The row's full 0.429 coefficient (our old engine; no log).
    Sims right if
    Rise ≈ 21 per 100 spell power.
    Alternative right if
    Rise ≈ 43 per 100 spell power.
    Impact
    wowsims's reading vs ours (our engine): Ret −2.2..−3.1 %, Shockadin −2.2..−2.9 %, prot paladin DPS −1.4..−3.1 %, TPS −1.9..−4.2 %.
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  10. 10Deep Wounds refresh: tick timerWarriorkeeps the timer (wowsims)4.3 %Fury DW · Reck, Arms · Reck15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 warrior, Deep Wounds 3/3, high crit (Fury gear), /combatlog on, a training dummy.
    2. Attack 5 min. List every Deep Wounds application/refresh and every tick with its timestamp.
    3. Pick 30+ refreshes that land between two ticks.
    4. For each, measure the time from the refreshing crit to the next tick.
    Sims now
    A refresh keeps the first application's tick timer (wowsims; no evidence cited). Owner's call, 12 Nov 21:44.
    Alternative
    A refresh restarts the timer and the owed damage rolls into the new bleed (our rule of 7 Oct; our old engine).
    Sims right if
    Ticks keep their old rhythm through refreshes.
    Alternative right if
    The next tick comes one full tick interval after the refreshing crit, every time.
    Impact
    Reset vs keep: Fury −4.1..−4.3 % 1 boss · 1 min, −3.3..−3.4 % 3 bosses · 1 min; Arms −1.1..−1.4 % (the reset is 47 of wowsims's 63 Deep Wounds DPS).
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  11. 11Vindication and Demoralizing Shout/Roar: stack or notDruidPaladinWarriorone category (wowsims)4.7 %Prot Pala · Mitigation, Prot Pala · Balanced, Prot Pala · Threat30 min, 2-3 players

    How to test

    1. A paladin with Vindication, a warrior with Demoralizing Shout (or a druid with Demoralizing Roar), a tank, a level 60 elite that hits the tank. /combatlog on.
    2. Phase A: Shout only. Phase B: Vindication only. Phase C: both. 100+ mob hits on the tank in each.
    3. In each phase, check the mob's debuff bar: do both show?
    4. Average the mob's normal hits (no crush, no block) per phase.
    Sims now
    Vindication shares Demoralizing Shout/Roar's category: only the stronger applies (wowsims 7a79ab991; no in-game check).
    Alternative
    Its own aura, both apply (our old engine; the 19 Oct test PAL-8 is still open).
    Sims right if
    Phase C = the stronger of A and B.
    Alternative right if
    Phase C lower than both A and B.
    Impact
    wowsims's reading vs ours: mitigation/balanced paladin DTPS +4.7 % 1 boss · 1 min, +1.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min; prot_paladin 3 bosses · 1 min +0.9 %. Survival scores move by about the DTPS change (estimated).
    Effort
    30 min, 2-3 players
  12. 12Gnomish Battle Chicken: how often it squawksDruidHunterPaladinRogueShamanWarriorevery summon (MythicSim, ours)≈2.7 %Arms · Reck, Fury DW · Reck, Bear (3 variants), Ret, Shockadin, Enh, Combat, Mutilate, Hemo, Survival melee, Cat, Prot Warr (3 variants)1 min a summon, but a 30 min cooldown: 10-20 summons over a week, solo or pooled

    How to test

    1. An engineer with Gnomish Battle Chicken, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Summon it in combat each time the 30 min cooldown is up. Note whether Battle Squawk appears (buff and log line).
    3. Once: note the buff's size (melee speed on the character sheet) and duration.
    4. Pool summons from several engineers.
    Sims now
    Battle Squawk (+5 % melee speed, 4 min) on every summon (MythicSim's reading). The buff itself is the client row (SpellEffect 699978).
    Alternative
    About one summon in two (Classic player reports; no Forever count).
    Sims right if
    Every summon squawks (10 of 10).
    Alternative right if
    Any summon without a squawk rules out 'always'; the share over 20+ summons is the rate to model.
    Impact
    Chicken on vs off: Arms +2.7..+3.8 %, Fury +3.4..+3.5 %, bears +3.1..+3.6 %, Ret 0..+5.3 %, Shockadin +2.6 %, rogues +1.6..+2.3 %, SV melee +2.3..+2.8 %, Enhancement +2.5 %, feral +1.8..+2.0 %, prot warriors +1.2..+2.1 %. A 50 % squawk halves each (estimated).
    Effort
    1 min a summon, but a 30 min cooldown: 10-20 summons over a week, solo or pooled
  13. 13Is Hurricane sped up by haste?Druidhasted (wowsims)3.6 %Balance15 min, solo (needs a haste source)

    How to test

    1. Balance druid, top Hurricane rank, /combatlog on, a group of dummies or mobs.
    2. 5 full Hurricanes with no haste: note the time between ticks and the tick count.
    3. 5 more under a cast-speed effect (haste rating gear, a haste trinket or buff).
    4. Compare tick spacing and channel length.
    Sims now
    Yes (wowsims; no source).
    Alternative
    No (forever-bugs #437, a tester report).
    Sims right if
    Ticks come faster under haste.
    Alternative right if
    Same spacing: reinstate the unhasted patch.
    Impact
    Unhasted vs hasted: Balance 3 bosses · 1 min −2.6/−3.6 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Builds
    Balance
    Effort
    15 min, solo (needs a haste source)
    Sources
    • forever-bugs #437
  14. 14Talisman of Ascendance: ends after 6 spells?DruidMagePaladinPriestShamanWarlock6 spells (ours, item text)3.6 %caster and healer builds wearing it (82 requests), Prot Pala · Threat5 min, solo (needs the trinket)

    How to test

    1. A caster with Talisman of Ascendance, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Use it; cast fast spells and count them until the buff fades (the log's 'fades' line).
    3. Do it 3 times; once with slow casts so 20 s comes first.
    Sims now
    Ends after the 6th damage or healing spell or 20 s (our patch, from the item text 'Expires after 6 damage or healing spells or 20 seconds').
    Alternative
    Runs the full 20 s (wowsims: the row's ProcCharges is 0).
    Sims right if
    It fades on the 6th spell.
    Alternative right if
    It lasts 20 s whatever you cast.
    Impact
    6-spell end vs 20 s: casters −1.3..−3.6 %, prot paladin TPS −1.5..−2.0 %, healers −0.5..−3.6 %. By build, wowsims's reading on our engine: Arcane +3.3..+3.5, Destruction +3.4..+3.7, Elemental +2.6..+3.9 %.
    Builds
    caster and healer builds wearing it (82 requests), Prot Pala · Threat
    Effort
    5 min, solo (needs the trinket)
  15. 15Low-rank spell power penalty at level 60DruidPaladinPriestour fitted formula4.0 %Smite, Holy Pala · Party, Holy Priest · Party, Resto Druid · Party10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 priest. Read the tooltip damage of Smite rank 6 (max level 43), rank 4 and the top rank.
    2. Add about +100 spell power (item or elixir); read the three tooltips again.
    3. If a tooltip is unclear, 20 non-crit casts of that rank at each spell power level.
    4. Share kept = rank's rise ÷ the top rank's rise (same 2.5 s cast).
    Sims now
    Share = 1 − 0.05 × (60 − the rank's max level − 12), floored at 0 (Blizzard 1 Oct and 2 Nov notes say low ranks lose spell power, with no formula; this one is our fit to tooltips at levels 18-30).
    Alternative
    Another formula at 60, or none (wowsims's base has no penalty).
    Sims right if
    Rank 6 keeps about 75 %, rank 4 none.
    Alternative right if
    Other values: refit the formula at 60.
    Impact
    Penalty vs none: Smite −1.5..−4.0 %, Holy paladin party −1.1..−1.6 %, Holy priest party 0..−0.7 %, resto druid party −0.4 %. Most of Smite's part is a rank-2 fallback the re-optimisation should drop.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  16. 16Deadly Poison: attack power per tick or per applicationRogueper application (wowsims)2.5 %Combat, Mutilate, Hemo15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 rogue, Deadly Poison (trainer rank IV) on a weapon, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
    2. Build 5 stacks; read 10 ticks.
    3. Change AP by about 300 (an AP item or buff), let the stacks fall off, rebuild 5, read 10 ticks.
    4. Tick change ÷ (5 stacks × AP change).
    Sims now
    0.009 × AP a stack spread over 4 ticks, 0.00225 a tick (wowsims, 'Confirmed by Zirene', no log).
    Alternative
    0.009 × AP a stack on every tick (our old patch; one beta log, report 2701, ~363 AP, rank 1).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.00225 (300 AP, 5 stacks: +3.4 a tick).
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.009 (+13.5 a tick).
    Impact
    Per tick vs spread: Combat +0.7..+1.0 %, Mutilate +2.3..+2.5 %, Subtlety +2.0..+2.3 %.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  17. 17Does the Mutilate cast itself roll on-hit effects?Roguecast rolls (wowsims)2.8 %Mutilate15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 Mutilate rogue, Instant Poison on the main hand only, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 100+ Mutilates; ignore white swings (match by timestamp).
    3. Count main-hand Instant Poison procs at each Mutilate's timestamp, and Mutilates with two procs.
    Sims now
    Yes: the cast rolls main-hand procs besides its two strikes (wowsims; its own TODO 'double MH poison proc'; no log).
    Alternative
    Only the two hand strikes roll (our old patch; no log).
    Sims right if
    About twice the poison's chance a Mutilate, some with two procs.
    Alternative right if
    About the chance once, never two.
    Impact
    Strikes only vs cast too: Mutilate −2.6..−2.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, −2.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Builds
    Mutilate
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  18. 18Level-based partial resists on a level 63 bossDruidMagePriestShamanWarlocknone (both engines)≈6.0 %every caster DPS buildOne raid night of logs, needs a raid

    How to test

    1. Needs a level 63 boss (raids open 9 Dec).
    2. Any caster, /combatlog on, a school the boss doesn't resist.
    3. Log 300+ landed spell hits (normal raid play is enough).
    4. Count partial resists (a resisted amount on a hit).
    Sims now
    None (both engines; wowsims's logs show none at +2 levels, 49,488 hits). Nobody has logged +3.
    Alternative
    Classic-style level-based partial resists at +3.
    Sims right if
    No, or almost no, partial resists.
    Alternative right if
    Regular 25/50/75 % partials: model level-based resists.
    Impact
    Not measured this round. The 3 Nov review put the lift from dropping level-based partial resists at up to 6-9 % for casters; the same swing back (estimated).
    Builds
    every caster DPS build
    Effort
    One raid night of logs, needs a raid
  19. 19Shield Slam Rank 4 flat threatWarrior267 (wowsims)3.9 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 prot warrior, Shield Slam Rank 4, Defensive Stance, a training dummy or a mob you can tank. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
    2. Calibrate: threat ÷ damage on 20 white hits = stance multiplier M.
    3. 15+ non-crit Shield Slams with nothing else in the same instant; 5+ crits.
    4. Flat part = (threat gained − damage × M) ÷ M.
    Sims now
    267, added once on a crit (wowsims: Rank 1 measured at 177.7, levels 40-42, n 28 and 16; Ranks 2-4 carried by spell level, never measured).
    Alternative
    508 (our old Classic ×2 carry-over, no Forever source), or nearer Rank 1's 178.
    Sims right if
    ≈ 267.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 508, or ≈ 178: set that value.
    Impact
    508 vs 267: prot warrior TPS +3.3 %, balanced +3.9 % 1 boss · 1 min; +2.6 %, +2.9..+3.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min. 178 vs 508: −4.4..−6.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, so about −1..−2 % against 267 (estimated).
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  20. 20Fiery Weapon (and Lifestealing) proc rateHunter6 PPM (ours)2.1 %Survival melee15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Any melee with Enchant Weapon - Fiery Weapon, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note weapon speed.
    2. Auto-attack 10 min (no extra-attack effects).
    3. Count Fiery Weapon hits; per minute = count ÷ 10.
    4. Optional: another weapon speed (per minute or per hit).
    Sims now
    Fiery Weapon 6 procs a minute, Lifestealing 6.66 (Classic rates; no Forever row states one; wowsims gives both no effect).
    Alternative
    Another rate (no source).
    Sims right if
    About 6 a minute (60 ± 8 in 10 min).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set the rate.
    Impact
    Fiery Weapon on vs off: SV melee +1.9..+2.1 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..+1.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Lifestealing is not worn.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  21. 21Eviscerate attack power per combo pointRogue0.04 (wowsims)1.7 %Combat, Mutilate, Hemo20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 rogue, top Eviscerate rank, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
    2. 30+ non-crit 5-point Eviscerates.
    3. Change AP by about 500 (buffs, elixirs or AP items); 30+ more.
    4. Rise in the average ÷ (5 × AP change).
    Sims now
    0.04 × AP a point (wowsims, 'estimated from in-game tests', no log shown).
    Alternative
    0.03 × AP a point (our old reading; no log).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.04 (500 AP: +100 a hit).
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.03 (+75 a hit).
    Impact
    0.04 vs 0.03: Combat +0.9..+1.0 %, Mutilate +1.6..+1.7 %, Subtlety +0.5..+0.6 % (our engine).
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  22. 22Soulforge 4-piece: Crusader's Wrath ratePaladin3 PPM (ours)1.8 %Prot Pala · Threat, Ret20 min, solo (needs the set)

    How to test

    1. Paladin in 4 original Soulforge pieces, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note weapon speed.
    2. Auto-attack (with your normal rotation) 15 min.
    3. Count Crusader's Wrath procs; per minute = count ÷ minutes.
    4. Optional: repeat with a weapon of another speed (per minute or per hit).
    Sims now
    3 procs a minute (our engine's literal; no row or text states a rate; wowsims models none).
    Alternative
    Any other rate (no source).
    Sims right if
    About 3 a minute (45 ± 7 in 15 min).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set the rate.
    Impact
    Proc on vs none: prot paladin TPS +1.3..+1.8 %, Ret 3 bosses · 1 min +1.8 % (alliance). Scales with the rate.
    Effort
    20 min, solo (needs the set)
  23. 23Ice Lance spell power coefficientMage1/7 (wowsims)1.9 %Frost15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 Frost mage, top Ice Lance rank, /combatlog on, a dummy that is not frozen.
    2. 30+ non-crit Ice Lances at normal spell power.
    3. Add 200+ frost spell power; 30+ more.
    4. Rise ÷ spell power added.
    Sims now
    1/7 ≈ 0.143 (wowsims, a TBC carry-over with its own 'until measured' TODO).
    Alternative
    0.10 (our old value from two level-26 beta logs, 84 hits at ~80 spell power).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.143.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.10.
    Impact
    0.10 vs 1/7: Frost −1.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.7 % 3 bosses · 1 min; 1/7 on our engine +1.3/+1.9 %.
    Builds
    Frost
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  24. 24Do Flamestrike's tick crits light Ignite?Mageticks ignite (ours)5.1 %Fire, Frostfire15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Fire mage with Ignite, /combatlog on, 2-3 dummies.
    2. 20+ Flamestrikes. Find tick crits with no other crit within 2 s.
    3. Check whether an Ignite application or refresh follows each.
    Sims now
    Yes (our patch; Blizzard 2 Nov notes: Ignite now applies past Flamestrike's first hit; tick crits seen in foreverlogs 2668).
    Alternative
    Only the first hit's crits (wowsims: its Ignite trigger hears direct hits only).
    Sims right if
    Ignite follows tick crits.
    Alternative right if
    Never.
    Impact
    Tick Ignite vs none: Fire 3 bosses · 1 min +5.05/+5.11 %, Frostfire +4.90/+4.09 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  25. 25Thunder Clap attack power share at the top rankWarrior0.07 (wowsims)2.9 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 warrior, top Thunder Clap rank, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 30+ non-crit Thunder Claps at normal AP.
    3. Change AP by about 500; 30+ more.
    4. Rise ÷ AP change.
    Sims now
    0.07 × AP (wowsims #931, measured on Ranks 1 and 4 at levels 43-45; no sample size given).
    Alternative
    0.0255 × AP (our old fit, 61 rank 1 hits at level 20).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.07.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.026. Another value at the top rank: set it.
    Impact
    0.07 vs 0.0255: prot TPS 1 boss · 1 min +0.3 % (mitigation +1.3..+1.4 %), 3 bosses · 1 min +2.4..+2.9 %; DPS 3 bosses · 1 min +3.0..+4.4 % (our engine).
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  26. 26Immolation Trap attack power shareHunter10 % of RAP (wowsims)1.4 %Survival melee, Survival weave20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 hunter, top Immolation Trap rank, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note melee AP, ranged AP and Clever Traps rank.
    2. 5 traps; sum each trap's ticks.
    3. Raise ranged AP only by ~300 (a ranged-AP item); 5 more traps.
    4. Raise melee AP only by ~300 (a melee-AP item or buff); 5 more traps.
    Sims now
    10 % of ranged AP over the ticks (wowsims, 'the Forever notes'; no number in the 15 Oct or 2 Nov text).
    Alternative
    13.2 % of the higher of melee and ranged AP (forever-bugs #283, a combat-log fit with Clever Traps 2/2).
    Sims right if
    Total rises ≈ 0.10 × ranged AP added, not with melee AP.
    Alternative right if
    Rises ≈ 0.132 × whichever AP is higher.
    Impact
    13.2 % vs 10 %: SV melee +0.7 % 1 boss · 1 min. 10 % on our engine: SV melee −0.6 / −1.3..−1.4 %, SV weave −0.4 / −0.9..−1.0 %, BM/MM 1 boss · 1 min −0.2..−0.3 %.
    Effort
    20 min, solo
    Sources
    • forever-bugs #283
  27. 27Shieldsworn: does Holy Strike roll Reckoning?Paladinno Reckoning (wowsims)2.5 %Prot Pala · Threat, Prot Pala · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Prot paladin, Shieldsworn and Reckoning 5/5, a shield, Holy Shield off, /combatlog on.
    2. A dummy that doesn't attack; Holy Strike only, 50+ times.
    3. Count Reckoning charges or extra attacks.
    Sims now
    No: Holy Strike activates Holy Shield and Shield Specialization only (wowsims; the live Wowhead tooltip of 1328544 names just these two).
    Alternative
    Also Reckoning (our old engine; 2 Nov notes: 'all talents that activate when you block').
    Sims right if
    None in 50+.
    Alternative right if
    Any Reckoning charge.
    Impact
    wowsims's reading vs ours: prot DPS −1.7..−3.2 %, TPS −1.2..−2.5 %.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  28. 28Lacerating Strikes refresh: replace or roll overHunterreplaces (ours)2.0 %Survival melee, Survival weave10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. SV hunter with Lacerating Strikes, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Refresh the bleed 20+ times before it runs out.
    3. Compare the tick size right before and right after each refresh.
    Sims now
    A refresh replaces the bleed on a fresh timer, no rollover (our rule + Blizzard notes 'always overwrites'; our patch).
    Alternative
    The remaining damage rolls into the new bleed (wowsims).
    Sims right if
    Same tick size after a refresh.
    Alternative right if
    Bigger ticks after a refresh.
    Impact
    Replace vs rollover: SV melee −1.9..−2.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.5..−1.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min; SV weave −0.9..−1.0 / −0.6..−0.7 %.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  29. 29Windfury Totem swings and Unsealed Wrath Echoes (11 Nov hotfix)Paladinno Echo (ours, Blizzard text)2.0 %Ret15 min, needs a shaman

    How to test

    1. Ret paladin with Unsealed Wrath, a shaman's Windfury Totem, a seal up, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack; check Echo stacks (buff bar or log) right after each WF Totem proc.
    3. Get 30+ WF procs.
    Sims now
    A WF Totem extra attack stores and spends no Echo (Blizzard 11 Nov hotfix, server-side, no row; our patch).
    Alternative
    WF swings store Echoes (both engines before the hotfix; true if the hotfix isn't live as written).
    Sims right if
    No stack after any WF proc.
    Alternative right if
    Stacks after WF procs: drop the patch.
    Impact
    No Echo vs Echo: Ret −1.9..−2.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.2..−1.3 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Builds
    Ret
    Effort
    15 min, needs a shaman
  30. 30Auto Shot's 0.5 s stand-still: does haste shorten it?Hunterhasted wind-up (wowsims)≈1.0 %Survival weave, BM20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter with a swing-timer addon, screen recording at 60 fps, a dummy.
    2. 20 times: move, stop; count frames from the stop to the Auto Shot release.
    3. 20 more under Rapid Fire (or another ranged haste).
    Sims now
    Yes: a 0.5 s wind-up shortened by ranged haste (wowsims #733, from sim scenarios).
    Alternative
    0.5 s after the last move, unhasted (our old engine; Blizzard 15 Oct notes give the 0.5 s, 'matching Classic').
    Sims right if
    Shorter under haste.
    Alternative right if
    Still 0.5 s.
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: under 1 % on the weave builds.
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  31. 31Rage decay before the pullDruidWarriordecays (ours)1.5 %Fury DW · Reck, Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 warrior out of combat with a rage readout (a /run print(UnitPower('player')) macro, or the bar).
    2. Bloodrage out of combat: note whether you enter combat (combat icon); read rage each second for 5 s.
    3. Same with Berserker Rage (and a druid's Enrage), then pull a dummy and note rage at the pull.
    4. Repeat with Anger Management if you have it.
    Sims now
    Rage decays 1.25 a second out of combat (client PowerType Rage RegenPeace −12.5), 30 % less with Anger Management, never below the starting rage; a pre-pull Bloodrage or Berserker Rage partly decays (our patch).
    Alternative
    No pre-pull decay (wowsims's base), e.g. if those effects put you in combat.
    Sims right if
    Rage falls ~1.25 a second right after the effect, out of combat.
    Alternative right if
    Rage holds until the pull.
    Impact
    Decay vs none: Fury −0.5..−0.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..−1.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min; bears −0.5..−1.5 % TPS 1 boss · 1 min, −0.2..−0.9 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  32. 32Dungeon set 2 four-piece procs: Warrior's Resolve, Rogue Armor EnergizeRogueWarrior1 PPM (ours)1.1 %Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Warr · Mitigation, rogues in Darkmantle20 min per set, solo (needs the set)

    How to test

    1. Warrior in 4 original Battlegear of Heroism pieces (or a rogue in 4 Darkmantle), /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack 15 min.
    3. Count Warrior's Resolve (or Rogue Armor Energize) procs; per minute = count ÷ 15.
    Sims now
    1 proc a minute each (our engine's literals; the rows state no rate; wowsims models none).
    Alternative
    Any other rate (no source).
    Sims right if
    About 1 a minute (15 ± 4).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set the rate.
    Impact
    Heroism 4pc (Warrior's Resolve) on vs off, our old engine: prot warrior balanced/mitigation TPS −0.2..−1.1 %. Rogue Armor Energize not measured. Worn active bonuses on 1 boss · 1 min + 3 bosses · 1 min: Heroism 16, Darkmantle 5.
    Builds
    Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Warr · Mitigation, rogues in Darkmantle
    Effort
    20 min per set, solo (needs the set)
  33. 33Battle Shout over an equal raid shoutWarriorrecasts (wowsims)0.9 %Arms · Reck5 min, two warriors

    How to test

    1. Two level 60 warriors with the same top trainer Battle Shout rank.
    2. Warrior A shouts. Warrior B shouts while A's buff is up.
    3. Note B's result: refused with an error, a refresh, or B's buff replacing A's; and whether B spent rage and a GCD.
    Sims now
    The warrior's own Battle Shout recasts over the raid's equal-rank shout (wowsims engine; only its Protection rotation skips it).
    Alternative
    An equal shout is not recast (our old engine rule; no source).
    Sims right if
    B's shout goes off and refreshes (then skipping it is a rotation choice for the re-optimisation).
    Alternative right if
    B's shout is refused, no rage or GCD spent: the engine must not recast it.
    Impact
    No recast vs recast: Arms 3 bosses · 1 min +0.6..+0.9 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Effort
    5 min, two warriors
  34. 34Shank: procs and off-hand talentsRogueno procs, no off-hand talents (wowsims)1.5 %Combat20 min, solo (+ a respec or a second rogue)

    How to test

    1. Combat rogue, Instant Poison on the off hand only, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Macro /cast Shank + /stopattack; 100 Shanks with no white swings.
    3. Count poison procs at Shank's timestamps.
    4. Average non-crit Shank with Dual Wield Specialization 2/2, then 0/2 (respec, or a second rogue with the same off hand).
    Sims now
    Shank triggers no procs (row attributes; wowsims's own ruling waits for an in-game check) and takes no off-hand talents (Dual Wield Specialization, Hack and Slash's off-hand crit).
    Alternative
    Shank rolls off-hand poison, enchant and item procs and takes the off-hand talents (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    No procs, no change with DW Spec.
    Alternative right if
    Procs: Shank rolls procs. Higher with DW Spec: give Shank the talent.
    Impact
    wowsims's Shank vs ours: Combat −1.3..−1.5 % 1 boss · 1 min, −0.4..−1.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min; with DW Spec kept on Shank −0.5..−0.7 / −0.1..−0.7 %. Mutilate and Subtlety within ±0.4 %.
    Builds
    Combat
    Effort
    20 min, solo (+ a respec or a second rogue)
  35. 35Multi-Shot: whose Hunter's Mark each arrow readsHunterown target's mark (ours)1.1 %BM, MM, MM Lone Wolf, Survival weave15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter, /combatlog on, 3 dummies or mobs side by side.
    2. Mark target A. 30 Multi-Shots at A.
    3. Compare non-crit arrow damage on A with B and C.
    Sims now
    Each arrow reads its own target's Hunter's Mark (our patch; the mark's tooltip: 'against the target').
    Alternative
    Every arrow uses the primary target's ranged AP (wowsims).
    Sims right if
    B and C lower than A.
    Alternative right if
    All equal.
    Impact
    Own vs primary's: 3 bosses · 1 min BM −0.8..−0.9 %, MM −0.9..−1.1 %, Lone Wolf −1.1 %, SV weave −0.6..−0.8 %; 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  36. 36Raptor Strike queued on the walk-inHunterqueues on the walk-in (wowsims)≈1.0 %Survival weave10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 10 times: walk in from 10 yd pressing Raptor Strike before you reach melee range.
    3. Is the first melee hit Raptor Strike? Does pressing it out of range give an error?
    Sims now
    A Raptor Strike pressed on the walk-in queues and takes the first swing on arrival (wowsims).
    Alternative
    It only queues in melee range, so the rotation presses it on arrival (our old engine held the arrival swing for that).
    Sims right if
    It queues out of range; the first hit is Raptor Strike.
    Alternative right if
    Error out of range; the first hit is white.
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: under 1 % on the weaves.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  37. 37Does the hunter pet take its owner's melee speed?Hunterinherits (wowsims)2.5 %BM, MM10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 hunter with a pet, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Pet auto-attacks 2 min: average time between pet white swings.
    3. Rapid Fire; the same from 5 s after the cast.
    Sims now
    Yes: owner's melee and attack speed (Rapid Fire, Wind Blessed, Berserking), never ranged haste, at the next pet heartbeat (wowsims #909: one level-36 log, 12 Rapid Fire changes).
    Alternative
    The pet takes none of its owner's speed (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    Pet swings ~40 % faster under Rapid Fire.
    Alternative right if
    No change.
    Impact
    Inherit vs none: BM +2.3..+2.5 % 1 boss · 1 min, +1.2..+2.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min; MM +0.7..+0.9 % (our engine).
    Builds
    BM, MM
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  38. 38Teebu's Blazing Longsword: Firebolt rateHunterRogueWarrior1 PPM (ours)1.1 %Survival melee, Fury DW · Reck, Combat, Hemo20 min, solo (needs the sword)

    How to test

    1. Anyone with Teebu's Blazing Longsword, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack 15 min.
    3. Count Firebolt procs; per minute = count ÷ 15.
    Sims now
    Firebolt (140 Fire) at 1 proc a minute (wowsims/classic rate; no Forever row states one).
    Alternative
    Any other rate.
    Sims right if
    About 1 a minute (15 ± 4).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set it.
    Impact
    Proc on vs none: SV melee +1.0..+1.1 %, Fury +0.6..+0.9 %, Combat +0.6..+0.8 %, Subtlety +0.8..+0.9 %. Half weight: the strict pool drops Teebu's (no Wowhead source since 12 Nov) at the re-optimisation unless unsourced world drops stay.
    Effort
    20 min, solo (needs the sword)
  39. 39Does Stormstrike roll Windfury Totem?Shamanno roll (wowsims)≈1.0 %Enh15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Enhancement shaman, Rockbiter on the weapon, own Windfury Totem down, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 100+ Stormstrikes over 10-15 min.
    3. Count WF Totem extra attacks at a Stormstrike's timestamp, and after white swings.
    Sims now
    No (wowsims #910: its row lacks the main-hand-required and next-swing bits; not logged).
    Alternative
    Yes, as a main-hand special (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    None off 100 Stormstrikes (white swings about 18 %).
    Alternative right if
    About the white-swing rate.
    Impact
    Not measured alone. #910's whole Windfury rule: Enhancement −1.8..−1.9 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.3..−1.5 % 3 bosses · 1 min; the Stormstrike share is unknown, estimated up to about 1 %.
    Builds
    Enh
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  40. 40Epic shields' block valuePaladinWarrior66 (ours, Wowhead)1.0 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Pala · Balanced2 min, solo (needs the shield or a link)

    How to test

    1. Anyone holding or seeing The Immovable Object (or another epic shield a saved tank wears).
    2. Read the block value on the tooltip; worn, compare Block on the character sheet with and without it.
    Sims now
    From Wowhead's Forever planner: The Immovable Object 66 (our patch).
    Alternative
    The client's TBC block table: 79 (wowsims).
    Sims right if
    66.
    Alternative right if
    79.
    Impact
    66 vs 79: prot warrior TPS −0.3..−0.4 %, balanced −0.6..−1.0 %, prot paladin balanced −0.4..−0.5 %.
    Effort
    2 min, solo (needs the shield or a link)
  41. 41Judgement as a ranged attack (11 Nov hotfix)Paladinranged (ours, Blizzard text)0.8 %Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat30-40 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Human paladin with a sword or mace, no hit gear, /combatlog on, a level 63 dummy (or the highest-level target you can hit).
    2. 200 Judgements of Righteousness.
    3. Count misses; count Crusader or Hand of Justice procs at a judgement's timestamp.
    Sims now
    Damaging judgements use the ranged hit table and trigger no melee procs (Blizzard 11 Nov hotfix, server-side, no row; our patch).
    Alternative
    Melee attacks with melee procs (both engines before the hotfix).
    Sims right if
    About 8 % misses and no item procs (ranged table, no racial weapon skill).
    Alternative right if
    About 6 % and item procs: still melee.
    Impact
    Ranged vs melee: Ret −0.4..−0.8 %, Shockadin −0.4..−0.7 %, prot −0.2..−0.5 %. Hit-capped sets see no miss change.
    Effort
    30-40 min, solo
  42. 42Unsealed Wrath Echoes after a main-hand swapPaladincleared (wowsims)0.9 %Ret10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Ret paladin with Unsealed Wrath and two main-hand weapons (e.g. Manual Crowd Pummeler), /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Build Echo stacks, swap the main hand, check the buff bar and the log.
    3. Repeat 10 times.
    Sims now
    A main-hand swap clears every stored Echo (wowsims #923: level 20-35 logs with no counts; the row gained EquipClass 2 in push 113772).
    Alternative
    Echoes survive the swap (our old engine; the Manual Crowd Pummeler swap kept them).
    Sims right if
    Echoes gone after every swap.
    Alternative right if
    Echoes stay.
    Impact
    Clear vs keep: Ret −0.42/−0.89 % 1 boss · 1 min, −0.26/−0.36 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Builds
    Ret
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  43. 43Sword Specialization off a Windfury Totem swingWarriorno proc (wowsims)≈1.0 %Arms · Reck (horde)30-40 min, needs a shaman

    How to test

    1. Horde Arms warrior, Sword Specialization 5/5, a sword, a shaman's Windfury Totem, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack until you have 150+ Windfury Totem extra swings (about 30 min).
    3. Count Sword Specialization extra swings right after a WF swing, and after other hits.
    Sims now
    A Windfury Totem swing never brings a Sword Specialization extra swing (wowsims #897: 0 of 6 cases).
    Alternative
    WF Totem swings proc it like other hits (our old Classic carry-over).
    Sims right if
    None after 150 WF swings while other hits proc ~4 %.
    Alternative right if
    About the same rate after WF swings.
    Impact
    Not measured alone. wowsims's whole Sword Spec rule: Arms −0.6..−0.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, −2.1..−2.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min; the WF part moves horde Arms only, estimated −0.5..−1 %.
    Effort
    30-40 min, needs a shaman
  44. 44Cat finishers' attack power shares at the top ranksDruidwowsims's shares0.8 %Cat30 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 cat druid, top ranks, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
    2. 20 five-point Rips (read the ticks), 20 Rakes, 30 non-crit five-point Bites.
    3. Change AP by about 500 and repeat.
    4. Rise ÷ AP change for each.
    Sims now
    Rip 0.0114 × AP × min(CP, 4) a tick, Rake 0.065, Ferocious Bite 0.037 × AP a point (wowsims logs on ranks 1-4 at levels 22-51 with counts; ranks 5-6 extrapolated).
    Alternative
    Other values at the top ranks (our old placeholder: Rip 0.0125).
    Sims right if
    ≈ the shares above.
    Alternative right if
    Other values: set the top-rank shares.
    Impact
    wowsims's values vs ours: cat −0.7..−0.8 % (our engine).
    Builds
    Cat
    Effort
    30 min, solo
  45. 45Frostfire Bolt against Fire/Frost resistanceMagelowest resistance (ours)0.7 %Frostfire20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Frostfire mage, /combatlog on, a target with Fire or Frost resistance (an elemental mob).
    2. 100+ Frostfire Bolts; count partial resists.
    3. The same number of Fireballs and Frostbolts on that target.
    Sims now
    Meets the lower of the target's Fire and Frost resistance, each school's own piercing (our patch; the tooltip; wowsims's own comment says 'least resistance').
    Alternative
    A mixed school with resistance 0 and piercing ignored (wowsims code).
    Sims right if
    FFB partials ≈ the less-resisted school's.
    Alternative right if
    FFB never partially resisted.
    Impact
    Our rule vs wowsims's: Frostfire +0.5/+0.7 % 1 boss · 1 min.
    Builds
    Frostfire
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  46. 46Hunter pet ability global cooldownHunter1.5 s (wowsims)≈0.5 %BM5 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter with a pet at full Focus, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Let the pet use its abilities 2 min with Focus never short.
    3. Average the gap between back-to-back pet ability casts.
    Sims now
    1.5 s (the row; wowsims).
    Alternative
    1.6 s: the row plus a 0.1 s pet AI delay (our old hand value).
    Sims right if
    1.5 s.
    Alternative right if
    About 1.6 s.
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: under 0.5 % on BM.
    Builds
    BM
    Effort
    5 min, solo
  47. 47Judgement of the Crusader on damage shieldsPaladinno bonus (wowsims)0.9 %Prot Pala · Threat15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 paladin with Retribution Aura, a mob that hits you, /combatlog on.
    2. Judge Seal of the Crusader on it; log 30+ Ret Aura hits with the judgement up and 30+ without.
    3. Compare the averages.
    Sims now
    Adds nothing to damage-shield hits (Retribution Aura, Thorns, item shields) (wowsims #872: 9/9 rank 1 Ret Aura hits at levels 1-19).
    Alternative
    Damage shields take the target's holy bonus (our old engine: Ret Aura 0.06 × the bonus).
    Sims right if
    Same average.
    Alternative right if
    Higher with the judgement up.
    Impact
    None vs bonus: prot paladin −0.42 % DPS / −0.44 % TPS 1 boss · 1 min, −0.82 / −0.88 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  48. 48Skyborne races' base statsall classes on High Order or Windshaperwowsims #881 sheets0.4 %builds at a Skyborne race (Balance, feral horde, Frost, Frostfire, Arcane alliance, High Order hunters)10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Make a level 1 High Order and a level 1 Windshaper of one class, and one character of that class on another race.
    2. Remove all gear; read Str/Agi/Sta/Int/Spi.
    3. Skyborne offset = its stat − the other race's stat + that race's known offset.
    Sims now
    wowsims #881 level-1 sheets (6 Nov, none attached): High Order −3 Str/+4 Agi/−1 Sta/+4 Int/−3 Spi, Windshaper −4/+3/0/−1/+3.
    Alternative
    Our old −1/+1/−1/+1/0 for both (22 Sep beta sheets). Blizzard 2 Nov notes: corrected, no numbers.
    Sims right if
    −3/+4/−1/+4/−3 and −4/+3/0/−1/+3.
    Alternative right if
    Other values: put the read values in.
    Impact
    wowsims's offsets vs ours: −0.2..+0.37 % on builds at a Skyborne race (High Order hunters +0.25..+0.37 %, Windshaper melee −0.1..−0.2 %).
    Builds
    builds at a Skyborne race (Balance, feral horde, Frost, Frostfire, Arcane alliance, High Order hunters)
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  49. 49Threat from rage gains: scaled by stance or notWarriorunscaled (wowsims)≈0.6 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced, Fury/Prot15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 prot warrior, Defensive Stance, Defiance, a mob that hits you. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
    2. Find 10+ Shield Specialization rage procs with nothing else in the same instant.
    3. Threat gained per proc.
    Sims now
    Rage from Shield Specialization, Master of Defense and Bloodrage's instant part makes 5 threat a rage, not scaled by stance or Defiance (wowsims #876/#882: level 6-24 logs, 8/8 clean windows, n 12).
    Alternative
    Scaled by the threat multiplier, ×2.16 in Defensive Stance with Defiance 3/3 (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 25 per 5-rage proc.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 54 (×2.16).
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: prot TPS −0.3..−0.6 % for the unscaled reading.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
Skip to content

In-game tests

Mechanics the sims assume but nobody has measured in game, largest estimated effect first: a result from any of them corrects the sims.

49 mechanics

  1. 1Maul threat multiplierDruid×1.75 (wowsims)36 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced15 min (45 min with the other three bear tests), solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 druid in Dire Bear Form, top Maul rank, a training dummy or a mob that can't kill you. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
    2. Calibrate: 20 plain white hits with nothing else in the same instant. Threat gained ÷ damage = form multiplier F.
    3. Queue Maul on 20+ swings. Keep only non-crit Mauls with no other event in the same instant (no Enrage, no Primal Fury or other rage gain).
    4. Each Maul: threat gained ÷ (damage × F). Plot threat against damage: a line through zero means no flat part.
    5. Run the Swipe, Primal Bite and Lacerate tests in the same session.
    Sims now
    ×1.75 on Maul's damage. wowsims #822, a hand value: its PR says no game file states it.
    Alternative
    ×1, plain damage threat: our 25 Oct value. No measurement either.
    Sims right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.75.
    Alternative right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.0 (our 25 Oct value). Any other ratio, or a flat part: a new value to model.
    Impact
    ×1.75 vs ×1: bear TPS +30.4..+33.7 % 1 boss · 1 min, +30.7..+36.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine). Maul, Swipe and Primal Bite together at our values: −21.5..−22.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, −35.3..−37.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min TPS.
    Effort
    15 min (45 min with the other three bear tests), solo
  2. 2Swipe threat multiplierDruid×1.75 (wowsims)24 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo (needs 2+ targets)

    How to test

    1. Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test.
    2. Stand at 2-3 mobs or dummies. Swipe 20+ times with auto-attack stopped (a /stopattack macro).
    3. Read threat gained on your current target per Swipe and that target's Swipe damage; non-crits only.
    4. Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F).
    Sims now
    ×1.75 (wowsims #822, a hand value with no source).
    Alternative
    ×1 (our 7 Oct value; the Season of Discovery ×2 was dropped then). No measurement.
    Sims right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.75.
    Alternative right if
    Ratio ≈ 1.0.
    Impact
    ×1.75 vs ×1: bear TPS +17.6..+23.5 % 3 bosses · 1 min; 1 boss · 1 min 0 (no Swipe on one boss) (our engine).
    Effort
    10 min, solo (needs 2+ targets)
  3. 3Do melee swings keep landing while you channel Volley?Hunterswings continue (wowsims)≈18 %Survival melee10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. A hunter with a melee weapon, Volley trained, a training dummy. Turn on /combatlog.
    2. Stand in melee range and start auto attack. Let three or four swings land.
    3. Channel Volley on the dummy for its full 6 s, still in melee range. Don't move or cast anything else.
    4. In the log, count melee swings (SWING_DAMAGE, SWING_MISSED) between Volley's start and its aura fading.
    5. Repeat three times with a slow weapon and three times with a fast one.
    Sims now
    Yes. Only a spell with a cast time holds a melee swing; a channel holds none, so a hunter in melee range keeps swinging through Volley's 6 s (wowsims sim/core/attack.go, sim/hunter/volley.go). Survival (melee) channels Volley from 2 targets: on 3 bosses for 1 min it channels 54 of 60 s, and Volley is 55 % of its damage.
    Alternative
    No: the channel stops or pauses melee swings, as it stops Auto Shot. No measurement either way.
    Sims right if
    Swings land through the channel at the weapon's normal speed (about 6 s ÷ weapon speed each).
    Alternative right if
    No swings during the channel, or one held to its end: melee swings pause while channelling.
    Impact
    Melee swings and Raptor Strike landing during the channels: 17.5 % of Survival (melee)'s damage on 3 bosses · 1 min (one logged fight, 13 Nov; estimated). Survival (melee) is #2 on 3 bosses · 1 min at 1,890; without them about 1,560, sixth. 1 boss · 1 min 0 (no Volley on one boss).
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  4. 4Is the 10 Nov Enhancement hotfix live?Shamannot live (client rows)16 %Enh5-10 min, solo; re-check each week

    How to test

    1. Any shaman with Stormstrike: read its tooltip (weapon damage %, cooldown) and time the cooldown once.
    2. Read the Mental Dexterity and Maelstrom Weapon talent tooltips at each rank.
    3. Windfury Weapon on the main hand and your own Windfury Totem down: hit a dummy 3 min with /combatlog on. Count procs of each (the log names both).
    4. Repeat after each weekly maintenance (next 17 Nov) until the values change.
    Sims now
    Pre-10 Nov values: Stormstrike 150 % weapon damage / 6 s cooldown, Mental Dexterity 50/100/150 % of Intellect as AP, Maelstrom Weapon 20 procs a minute at every rank and 4 % a stack per point, a main-hand Windfury Weapon replaces the party's Windfury Totem. Source: client rows of 12 Nov 06:16 UTC and player reports.
    Alternative
    Blizzard's 10 Nov hotfix list: Stormstrike 100 % / 8 s, Mental Dexterity 33/66/100 %, Maelstrom 20 % a stack at 6/7/8/9/10 procs a minute by rank, Windfury Weapon and Windfury Totem both proc.
    Sims right if
    150 % / 6 s, old talent text, only the weapon's Windfury procs.
    Alternative right if
    100 % / 8 s and the new text: model the block (the 71-line patch is measured). Both Windfury procs seen: drop the imbue-replaces-totem rule.
    Impact
    Stormstrike, Mental Dexterity and Maelstrom together: Enhancement −15.9/−16.2 % 1 boss · 1 min, −12.7/−13.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Pieces on our engine: Stormstrike −9.5..−9.8 %, Mental Dexterity −3.0..−3.1 %, Maelstrom −4.5..−4.6 % 1 boss · 1 min. Weapon + totem: 0 on saved sets (Rockbiter), a new candidate if live.
    Builds
    Enh
    Effort
    5-10 min, solo; re-check each week
  5. 5Lacerate threat multiplier at level 60Druid×10/3 (wowsims)47 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test, top Lacerate rank.
    2. 20+ non-crit Lacerate hits on one target with auto-attack stopped, and 30+ ticks.
    3. Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F), for hits and for ticks separately.
    4. Note the stack count at each hit (the sim counts the stack the hit adds).
    Sims now
    ×10/3 on hit and ticks (wowsims #945 threat log: rank 2 in Bear Form firm, 33/40 hit and 59/65 tick windows; later ranks in Dire Bear fit only in part, 37/80 and 46/74 windows, none at ×1 or ×3).
    Alternative
    ×1 (our 7 Oct value).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 3.33 on hits and ticks at the top rank.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 1.0. Any other value: model it.
    Impact
    ×10/3 vs ×1: bear TPS +42.8..+47.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..+2.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine).
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  6. 6Primal Bite threat multiplierDruid×3 (wowsims)13 %Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test, top Primal Bite rank.
    2. 20+ non-crit Primal Bites with auto-attack stopped.
    3. Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F); check for a flat part.
    Sims now
    ×3, no flat part (wowsims #822/#945: 'measured on the first two ranks', levels ~37-51, sample not published).
    Alternative
    ×2 (our 7 Oct value, from the 70170 note 'roughly doubled').
    Sims right if
    Ratio ≈ 3.
    Alternative right if
    Ratio ≈ 2.
    Impact
    ×3 vs ×2: bear TPS +12.3..+13.2 % 1 boss · 1 min, +8.4..+9.7 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine).
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  7. 7Chain Lightning overload chance per targetShamanfull chance (ours)13 %Ele20 min, solo (needs 3 targets)

    How to test

    1. Level 60 Elemental shaman, Lightning Overload at max rank, /combatlog on.
    2. One dummy: 100+ Lightning Bolts. Overloads ÷ casts = p.
    3. A group of 3+ mobs or dummies: 60+ Chain Lightnings that hit 3 targets (180+ target hits).
    4. Count overload copies per target hit (the log names the overload spell and its target).
    Sims now
    Full Lightning Overload chance on every target hit (our patch: the 408438 row and tooltip state one chance for both spells). No log.
    Alternative
    A third of the chance per target (wowsims code; its own PRs #821/#839 say no game file states it).
    Sims right if
    Overloads per target hit ≈ p.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ p/3. (180 target hits separate p from p/3 for any p above about 10 %.)
    Impact
    Full vs 1/3: Elemental 3 bosses · 1 min +12.0/+12.5 %, 1 boss · 1 min +0.7 %. Elemental is #1 on 3 bosses · 1 min (1,784); at 1/3 it falls behind Lone Wolf (estimated).
    Builds
    Ele
    Effort
    20 min, solo (needs 3 targets)
  8. 8Revelation enchant: which hits roll itDruidMagePriestShamandamaging hits + channel ticks (wowsims)7.1 %Frost, Balance, Ele, Shadow30 min, solo per class (a mage and a priest)

    How to test

    1. Level 60 mage with Revelation on the weapon, /combatlog on, 3+ dummies or mobs.
    2. Channel Blizzard for 100+ ticks. Count Revelation procs on a tick with no direct cast landing.
    3. Priest (or warlock) with Revelation: 100+ Shadow Word: Pain (or Corruption) casts on fresh targets. Count procs at the application.
    4. The rate (9 vs 8.85 %) needs thousands of hits: skip it.
    Sims now
    wowsims's rules: only landed hits that deal damage or heal, plus each tick a channel casts (Blizzard, Hurricane, totems). Source: the row's Can Proc From Procs flag and the tooltip; no log. Rate 9 % (MythicSim's log count is 8.85 %).
    Alternative
    Our old rules: any landed non-crit spell hit or heal, zero-damage landings included (dot application, channel start), never a channel tick.
    Sims right if
    Procs on ~9 % of Blizzard ticks, none on dot applications.
    Alternative right if
    None on ticks, ~9 % on applications. A mix: model each part as seen.
    Impact
    wowsims's rules vs ours (our engine): Frost 3 bosses · 1 min +7.1/+6.8 %, Balance 3 bosses · 1 min +5.5/+5.9 %, Elemental 3 bosses · 1 min +1.3/+2.1 %, Shadow −2.9 % 1 boss · 1 min, −3.3 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Ticks alone: Frost 3 bosses · 1 min +10.7 %.
    Effort
    30 min, solo per class (a mage and a priest)
  9. 9Holy Strike's spell power sharePaladin≈ 0.21 (wowsims)4.2 %Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat, Prot Pala · Balanced20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 paladin, Holy Strike Rank 8, no Judgement of the Crusader on the target, /combatlog on, a training dummy.
    2. 40+ non-crit Holy Strikes in normal gear; average them.
    3. Add about +100 spell power (an elixir or an item), nothing else; 40+ more.
    4. Rise in the average ÷ spell power added = the share.
    Sims now
    Spell power through the weapon percent: 0.429 × 50 % ≈ 0.21 at Rank 8 (wowsims, by analogy with the Seal of Command proc; no log).
    Alternative
    The row's full 0.429 coefficient (our old engine; no log).
    Sims right if
    Rise ≈ 21 per 100 spell power.
    Alternative right if
    Rise ≈ 43 per 100 spell power.
    Impact
    wowsims's reading vs ours (our engine): Ret −2.2..−3.1 %, Shockadin −2.2..−2.9 %, prot paladin DPS −1.4..−3.1 %, TPS −1.9..−4.2 %.
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  10. 10Deep Wounds refresh: tick timerWarriorkeeps the timer (wowsims)4.3 %Fury DW · Reck, Arms · Reck15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 warrior, Deep Wounds 3/3, high crit (Fury gear), /combatlog on, a training dummy.
    2. Attack 5 min. List every Deep Wounds application/refresh and every tick with its timestamp.
    3. Pick 30+ refreshes that land between two ticks.
    4. For each, measure the time from the refreshing crit to the next tick.
    Sims now
    A refresh keeps the first application's tick timer (wowsims; no evidence cited). Owner's call, 12 Nov 21:44.
    Alternative
    A refresh restarts the timer and the owed damage rolls into the new bleed (our rule of 7 Oct; our old engine).
    Sims right if
    Ticks keep their old rhythm through refreshes.
    Alternative right if
    The next tick comes one full tick interval after the refreshing crit, every time.
    Impact
    Reset vs keep: Fury −4.1..−4.3 % 1 boss · 1 min, −3.3..−3.4 % 3 bosses · 1 min; Arms −1.1..−1.4 % (the reset is 47 of wowsims's 63 Deep Wounds DPS).
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  11. 11Vindication and Demoralizing Shout/Roar: stack or notDruidPaladinWarriorone category (wowsims)4.7 %Prot Pala · Mitigation, Prot Pala · Balanced, Prot Pala · Threat30 min, 2-3 players

    How to test

    1. A paladin with Vindication, a warrior with Demoralizing Shout (or a druid with Demoralizing Roar), a tank, a level 60 elite that hits the tank. /combatlog on.
    2. Phase A: Shout only. Phase B: Vindication only. Phase C: both. 100+ mob hits on the tank in each.
    3. In each phase, check the mob's debuff bar: do both show?
    4. Average the mob's normal hits (no crush, no block) per phase.
    Sims now
    Vindication shares Demoralizing Shout/Roar's category: only the stronger applies (wowsims 7a79ab991; no in-game check).
    Alternative
    Its own aura, both apply (our old engine; the 19 Oct test PAL-8 is still open).
    Sims right if
    Phase C = the stronger of A and B.
    Alternative right if
    Phase C lower than both A and B.
    Impact
    wowsims's reading vs ours: mitigation/balanced paladin DTPS +4.7 % 1 boss · 1 min, +1.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min; prot_paladin 3 bosses · 1 min +0.9 %. Survival scores move by about the DTPS change (estimated).
    Effort
    30 min, 2-3 players
  12. 12Gnomish Battle Chicken: how often it squawksDruidHunterPaladinRogueShamanWarriorevery summon (MythicSim, ours)≈2.7 %Arms · Reck, Fury DW · Reck, Bear (3 variants), Ret, Shockadin, Enh, Combat, Mutilate, Hemo, Survival melee, Cat, Prot Warr (3 variants)1 min a summon, but a 30 min cooldown: 10-20 summons over a week, solo or pooled

    How to test

    1. An engineer with Gnomish Battle Chicken, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Summon it in combat each time the 30 min cooldown is up. Note whether Battle Squawk appears (buff and log line).
    3. Once: note the buff's size (melee speed on the character sheet) and duration.
    4. Pool summons from several engineers.
    Sims now
    Battle Squawk (+5 % melee speed, 4 min) on every summon (MythicSim's reading). The buff itself is the client row (SpellEffect 699978).
    Alternative
    About one summon in two (Classic player reports; no Forever count).
    Sims right if
    Every summon squawks (10 of 10).
    Alternative right if
    Any summon without a squawk rules out 'always'; the share over 20+ summons is the rate to model.
    Impact
    Chicken on vs off: Arms +2.7..+3.8 %, Fury +3.4..+3.5 %, bears +3.1..+3.6 %, Ret 0..+5.3 %, Shockadin +2.6 %, rogues +1.6..+2.3 %, SV melee +2.3..+2.8 %, Enhancement +2.5 %, feral +1.8..+2.0 %, prot warriors +1.2..+2.1 %. A 50 % squawk halves each (estimated).
    Effort
    1 min a summon, but a 30 min cooldown: 10-20 summons over a week, solo or pooled
  13. 13Is Hurricane sped up by haste?Druidhasted (wowsims)3.6 %Balance15 min, solo (needs a haste source)

    How to test

    1. Balance druid, top Hurricane rank, /combatlog on, a group of dummies or mobs.
    2. 5 full Hurricanes with no haste: note the time between ticks and the tick count.
    3. 5 more under a cast-speed effect (haste rating gear, a haste trinket or buff).
    4. Compare tick spacing and channel length.
    Sims now
    Yes (wowsims; no source).
    Alternative
    No (forever-bugs #437, a tester report).
    Sims right if
    Ticks come faster under haste.
    Alternative right if
    Same spacing: reinstate the unhasted patch.
    Impact
    Unhasted vs hasted: Balance 3 bosses · 1 min −2.6/−3.6 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Builds
    Balance
    Effort
    15 min, solo (needs a haste source)
    Sources
    • forever-bugs #437
  14. 14Talisman of Ascendance: ends after 6 spells?DruidMagePaladinPriestShamanWarlock6 spells (ours, item text)3.6 %caster and healer builds wearing it (82 requests), Prot Pala · Threat5 min, solo (needs the trinket)

    How to test

    1. A caster with Talisman of Ascendance, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Use it; cast fast spells and count them until the buff fades (the log's 'fades' line).
    3. Do it 3 times; once with slow casts so 20 s comes first.
    Sims now
    Ends after the 6th damage or healing spell or 20 s (our patch, from the item text 'Expires after 6 damage or healing spells or 20 seconds').
    Alternative
    Runs the full 20 s (wowsims: the row's ProcCharges is 0).
    Sims right if
    It fades on the 6th spell.
    Alternative right if
    It lasts 20 s whatever you cast.
    Impact
    6-spell end vs 20 s: casters −1.3..−3.6 %, prot paladin TPS −1.5..−2.0 %, healers −0.5..−3.6 %. By build, wowsims's reading on our engine: Arcane +3.3..+3.5, Destruction +3.4..+3.7, Elemental +2.6..+3.9 %.
    Builds
    caster and healer builds wearing it (82 requests), Prot Pala · Threat
    Effort
    5 min, solo (needs the trinket)
  15. 15Low-rank spell power penalty at level 60DruidPaladinPriestour fitted formula4.0 %Smite, Holy Pala · Party, Holy Priest · Party, Resto Druid · Party10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 priest. Read the tooltip damage of Smite rank 6 (max level 43), rank 4 and the top rank.
    2. Add about +100 spell power (item or elixir); read the three tooltips again.
    3. If a tooltip is unclear, 20 non-crit casts of that rank at each spell power level.
    4. Share kept = rank's rise ÷ the top rank's rise (same 2.5 s cast).
    Sims now
    Share = 1 − 0.05 × (60 − the rank's max level − 12), floored at 0 (Blizzard 1 Oct and 2 Nov notes say low ranks lose spell power, with no formula; this one is our fit to tooltips at levels 18-30).
    Alternative
    Another formula at 60, or none (wowsims's base has no penalty).
    Sims right if
    Rank 6 keeps about 75 %, rank 4 none.
    Alternative right if
    Other values: refit the formula at 60.
    Impact
    Penalty vs none: Smite −1.5..−4.0 %, Holy paladin party −1.1..−1.6 %, Holy priest party 0..−0.7 %, resto druid party −0.4 %. Most of Smite's part is a rank-2 fallback the re-optimisation should drop.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  16. 16Deadly Poison: attack power per tick or per applicationRogueper application (wowsims)2.5 %Combat, Mutilate, Hemo15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 rogue, Deadly Poison (trainer rank IV) on a weapon, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
    2. Build 5 stacks; read 10 ticks.
    3. Change AP by about 300 (an AP item or buff), let the stacks fall off, rebuild 5, read 10 ticks.
    4. Tick change ÷ (5 stacks × AP change).
    Sims now
    0.009 × AP a stack spread over 4 ticks, 0.00225 a tick (wowsims, 'Confirmed by Zirene', no log).
    Alternative
    0.009 × AP a stack on every tick (our old patch; one beta log, report 2701, ~363 AP, rank 1).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.00225 (300 AP, 5 stacks: +3.4 a tick).
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.009 (+13.5 a tick).
    Impact
    Per tick vs spread: Combat +0.7..+1.0 %, Mutilate +2.3..+2.5 %, Subtlety +2.0..+2.3 %.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  17. 17Does the Mutilate cast itself roll on-hit effects?Roguecast rolls (wowsims)2.8 %Mutilate15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 Mutilate rogue, Instant Poison on the main hand only, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 100+ Mutilates; ignore white swings (match by timestamp).
    3. Count main-hand Instant Poison procs at each Mutilate's timestamp, and Mutilates with two procs.
    Sims now
    Yes: the cast rolls main-hand procs besides its two strikes (wowsims; its own TODO 'double MH poison proc'; no log).
    Alternative
    Only the two hand strikes roll (our old patch; no log).
    Sims right if
    About twice the poison's chance a Mutilate, some with two procs.
    Alternative right if
    About the chance once, never two.
    Impact
    Strikes only vs cast too: Mutilate −2.6..−2.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, −2.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Builds
    Mutilate
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  18. 18Level-based partial resists on a level 63 bossDruidMagePriestShamanWarlocknone (both engines)≈6.0 %every caster DPS buildOne raid night of logs, needs a raid

    How to test

    1. Needs a level 63 boss (raids open 9 Dec).
    2. Any caster, /combatlog on, a school the boss doesn't resist.
    3. Log 300+ landed spell hits (normal raid play is enough).
    4. Count partial resists (a resisted amount on a hit).
    Sims now
    None (both engines; wowsims's logs show none at +2 levels, 49,488 hits). Nobody has logged +3.
    Alternative
    Classic-style level-based partial resists at +3.
    Sims right if
    No, or almost no, partial resists.
    Alternative right if
    Regular 25/50/75 % partials: model level-based resists.
    Impact
    Not measured this round. The 3 Nov review put the lift from dropping level-based partial resists at up to 6-9 % for casters; the same swing back (estimated).
    Builds
    every caster DPS build
    Effort
    One raid night of logs, needs a raid
  19. 19Shield Slam Rank 4 flat threatWarrior267 (wowsims)3.9 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 prot warrior, Shield Slam Rank 4, Defensive Stance, a training dummy or a mob you can tank. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
    2. Calibrate: threat ÷ damage on 20 white hits = stance multiplier M.
    3. 15+ non-crit Shield Slams with nothing else in the same instant; 5+ crits.
    4. Flat part = (threat gained − damage × M) ÷ M.
    Sims now
    267, added once on a crit (wowsims: Rank 1 measured at 177.7, levels 40-42, n 28 and 16; Ranks 2-4 carried by spell level, never measured).
    Alternative
    508 (our old Classic ×2 carry-over, no Forever source), or nearer Rank 1's 178.
    Sims right if
    ≈ 267.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 508, or ≈ 178: set that value.
    Impact
    508 vs 267: prot warrior TPS +3.3 %, balanced +3.9 % 1 boss · 1 min; +2.6 %, +2.9..+3.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min. 178 vs 508: −4.4..−6.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, so about −1..−2 % against 267 (estimated).
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  20. 20Fiery Weapon (and Lifestealing) proc rateHunter6 PPM (ours)2.1 %Survival melee15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Any melee with Enchant Weapon - Fiery Weapon, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note weapon speed.
    2. Auto-attack 10 min (no extra-attack effects).
    3. Count Fiery Weapon hits; per minute = count ÷ 10.
    4. Optional: another weapon speed (per minute or per hit).
    Sims now
    Fiery Weapon 6 procs a minute, Lifestealing 6.66 (Classic rates; no Forever row states one; wowsims gives both no effect).
    Alternative
    Another rate (no source).
    Sims right if
    About 6 a minute (60 ± 8 in 10 min).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set the rate.
    Impact
    Fiery Weapon on vs off: SV melee +1.9..+2.1 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..+1.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Lifestealing is not worn.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  21. 21Eviscerate attack power per combo pointRogue0.04 (wowsims)1.7 %Combat, Mutilate, Hemo20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 rogue, top Eviscerate rank, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
    2. 30+ non-crit 5-point Eviscerates.
    3. Change AP by about 500 (buffs, elixirs or AP items); 30+ more.
    4. Rise in the average ÷ (5 × AP change).
    Sims now
    0.04 × AP a point (wowsims, 'estimated from in-game tests', no log shown).
    Alternative
    0.03 × AP a point (our old reading; no log).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.04 (500 AP: +100 a hit).
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.03 (+75 a hit).
    Impact
    0.04 vs 0.03: Combat +0.9..+1.0 %, Mutilate +1.6..+1.7 %, Subtlety +0.5..+0.6 % (our engine).
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  22. 22Soulforge 4-piece: Crusader's Wrath ratePaladin3 PPM (ours)1.8 %Prot Pala · Threat, Ret20 min, solo (needs the set)

    How to test

    1. Paladin in 4 original Soulforge pieces, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note weapon speed.
    2. Auto-attack (with your normal rotation) 15 min.
    3. Count Crusader's Wrath procs; per minute = count ÷ minutes.
    4. Optional: repeat with a weapon of another speed (per minute or per hit).
    Sims now
    3 procs a minute (our engine's literal; no row or text states a rate; wowsims models none).
    Alternative
    Any other rate (no source).
    Sims right if
    About 3 a minute (45 ± 7 in 15 min).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set the rate.
    Impact
    Proc on vs none: prot paladin TPS +1.3..+1.8 %, Ret 3 bosses · 1 min +1.8 % (alliance). Scales with the rate.
    Effort
    20 min, solo (needs the set)
  23. 23Ice Lance spell power coefficientMage1/7 (wowsims)1.9 %Frost15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 Frost mage, top Ice Lance rank, /combatlog on, a dummy that is not frozen.
    2. 30+ non-crit Ice Lances at normal spell power.
    3. Add 200+ frost spell power; 30+ more.
    4. Rise ÷ spell power added.
    Sims now
    1/7 ≈ 0.143 (wowsims, a TBC carry-over with its own 'until measured' TODO).
    Alternative
    0.10 (our old value from two level-26 beta logs, 84 hits at ~80 spell power).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.143.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.10.
    Impact
    0.10 vs 1/7: Frost −1.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.7 % 3 bosses · 1 min; 1/7 on our engine +1.3/+1.9 %.
    Builds
    Frost
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  24. 24Do Flamestrike's tick crits light Ignite?Mageticks ignite (ours)5.1 %Fire, Frostfire15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Fire mage with Ignite, /combatlog on, 2-3 dummies.
    2. 20+ Flamestrikes. Find tick crits with no other crit within 2 s.
    3. Check whether an Ignite application or refresh follows each.
    Sims now
    Yes (our patch; Blizzard 2 Nov notes: Ignite now applies past Flamestrike's first hit; tick crits seen in foreverlogs 2668).
    Alternative
    Only the first hit's crits (wowsims: its Ignite trigger hears direct hits only).
    Sims right if
    Ignite follows tick crits.
    Alternative right if
    Never.
    Impact
    Tick Ignite vs none: Fire 3 bosses · 1 min +5.05/+5.11 %, Frostfire +4.90/+4.09 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  25. 25Thunder Clap attack power share at the top rankWarrior0.07 (wowsims)2.9 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 warrior, top Thunder Clap rank, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 30+ non-crit Thunder Claps at normal AP.
    3. Change AP by about 500; 30+ more.
    4. Rise ÷ AP change.
    Sims now
    0.07 × AP (wowsims #931, measured on Ranks 1 and 4 at levels 43-45; no sample size given).
    Alternative
    0.0255 × AP (our old fit, 61 rank 1 hits at level 20).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 0.07.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 0.026. Another value at the top rank: set it.
    Impact
    0.07 vs 0.0255: prot TPS 1 boss · 1 min +0.3 % (mitigation +1.3..+1.4 %), 3 bosses · 1 min +2.4..+2.9 %; DPS 3 bosses · 1 min +3.0..+4.4 % (our engine).
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  26. 26Immolation Trap attack power shareHunter10 % of RAP (wowsims)1.4 %Survival melee, Survival weave20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 hunter, top Immolation Trap rank, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note melee AP, ranged AP and Clever Traps rank.
    2. 5 traps; sum each trap's ticks.
    3. Raise ranged AP only by ~300 (a ranged-AP item); 5 more traps.
    4. Raise melee AP only by ~300 (a melee-AP item or buff); 5 more traps.
    Sims now
    10 % of ranged AP over the ticks (wowsims, 'the Forever notes'; no number in the 15 Oct or 2 Nov text).
    Alternative
    13.2 % of the higher of melee and ranged AP (forever-bugs #283, a combat-log fit with Clever Traps 2/2).
    Sims right if
    Total rises ≈ 0.10 × ranged AP added, not with melee AP.
    Alternative right if
    Rises ≈ 0.132 × whichever AP is higher.
    Impact
    13.2 % vs 10 %: SV melee +0.7 % 1 boss · 1 min. 10 % on our engine: SV melee −0.6 / −1.3..−1.4 %, SV weave −0.4 / −0.9..−1.0 %, BM/MM 1 boss · 1 min −0.2..−0.3 %.
    Effort
    20 min, solo
    Sources
    • forever-bugs #283
  27. 27Shieldsworn: does Holy Strike roll Reckoning?Paladinno Reckoning (wowsims)2.5 %Prot Pala · Threat, Prot Pala · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Prot paladin, Shieldsworn and Reckoning 5/5, a shield, Holy Shield off, /combatlog on.
    2. A dummy that doesn't attack; Holy Strike only, 50+ times.
    3. Count Reckoning charges or extra attacks.
    Sims now
    No: Holy Strike activates Holy Shield and Shield Specialization only (wowsims; the live Wowhead tooltip of 1328544 names just these two).
    Alternative
    Also Reckoning (our old engine; 2 Nov notes: 'all talents that activate when you block').
    Sims right if
    None in 50+.
    Alternative right if
    Any Reckoning charge.
    Impact
    wowsims's reading vs ours: prot DPS −1.7..−3.2 %, TPS −1.2..−2.5 %.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  28. 28Lacerating Strikes refresh: replace or roll overHunterreplaces (ours)2.0 %Survival melee, Survival weave10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. SV hunter with Lacerating Strikes, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Refresh the bleed 20+ times before it runs out.
    3. Compare the tick size right before and right after each refresh.
    Sims now
    A refresh replaces the bleed on a fresh timer, no rollover (our rule + Blizzard notes 'always overwrites'; our patch).
    Alternative
    The remaining damage rolls into the new bleed (wowsims).
    Sims right if
    Same tick size after a refresh.
    Alternative right if
    Bigger ticks after a refresh.
    Impact
    Replace vs rollover: SV melee −1.9..−2.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.5..−1.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min; SV weave −0.9..−1.0 / −0.6..−0.7 %.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  29. 29Windfury Totem swings and Unsealed Wrath Echoes (11 Nov hotfix)Paladinno Echo (ours, Blizzard text)2.0 %Ret15 min, needs a shaman

    How to test

    1. Ret paladin with Unsealed Wrath, a shaman's Windfury Totem, a seal up, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack; check Echo stacks (buff bar or log) right after each WF Totem proc.
    3. Get 30+ WF procs.
    Sims now
    A WF Totem extra attack stores and spends no Echo (Blizzard 11 Nov hotfix, server-side, no row; our patch).
    Alternative
    WF swings store Echoes (both engines before the hotfix; true if the hotfix isn't live as written).
    Sims right if
    No stack after any WF proc.
    Alternative right if
    Stacks after WF procs: drop the patch.
    Impact
    No Echo vs Echo: Ret −1.9..−2.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.2..−1.3 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Builds
    Ret
    Effort
    15 min, needs a shaman
  30. 30Auto Shot's 0.5 s stand-still: does haste shorten it?Hunterhasted wind-up (wowsims)≈1.0 %Survival weave, BM20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter with a swing-timer addon, screen recording at 60 fps, a dummy.
    2. 20 times: move, stop; count frames from the stop to the Auto Shot release.
    3. 20 more under Rapid Fire (or another ranged haste).
    Sims now
    Yes: a 0.5 s wind-up shortened by ranged haste (wowsims #733, from sim scenarios).
    Alternative
    0.5 s after the last move, unhasted (our old engine; Blizzard 15 Oct notes give the 0.5 s, 'matching Classic').
    Sims right if
    Shorter under haste.
    Alternative right if
    Still 0.5 s.
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: under 1 % on the weave builds.
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  31. 31Rage decay before the pullDruidWarriordecays (ours)1.5 %Fury DW · Reck, Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 warrior out of combat with a rage readout (a /run print(UnitPower('player')) macro, or the bar).
    2. Bloodrage out of combat: note whether you enter combat (combat icon); read rage each second for 5 s.
    3. Same with Berserker Rage (and a druid's Enrage), then pull a dummy and note rage at the pull.
    4. Repeat with Anger Management if you have it.
    Sims now
    Rage decays 1.25 a second out of combat (client PowerType Rage RegenPeace −12.5), 30 % less with Anger Management, never below the starting rage; a pre-pull Bloodrage or Berserker Rage partly decays (our patch).
    Alternative
    No pre-pull decay (wowsims's base), e.g. if those effects put you in combat.
    Sims right if
    Rage falls ~1.25 a second right after the effect, out of combat.
    Alternative right if
    Rage holds until the pull.
    Impact
    Decay vs none: Fury −0.5..−0.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..−1.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min; bears −0.5..−1.5 % TPS 1 boss · 1 min, −0.2..−0.9 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  32. 32Dungeon set 2 four-piece procs: Warrior's Resolve, Rogue Armor EnergizeRogueWarrior1 PPM (ours)1.1 %Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Warr · Mitigation, rogues in Darkmantle20 min per set, solo (needs the set)

    How to test

    1. Warrior in 4 original Battlegear of Heroism pieces (or a rogue in 4 Darkmantle), /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack 15 min.
    3. Count Warrior's Resolve (or Rogue Armor Energize) procs; per minute = count ÷ 15.
    Sims now
    1 proc a minute each (our engine's literals; the rows state no rate; wowsims models none).
    Alternative
    Any other rate (no source).
    Sims right if
    About 1 a minute (15 ± 4).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set the rate.
    Impact
    Heroism 4pc (Warrior's Resolve) on vs off, our old engine: prot warrior balanced/mitigation TPS −0.2..−1.1 %. Rogue Armor Energize not measured. Worn active bonuses on 1 boss · 1 min + 3 bosses · 1 min: Heroism 16, Darkmantle 5.
    Builds
    Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Warr · Mitigation, rogues in Darkmantle
    Effort
    20 min per set, solo (needs the set)
  33. 33Battle Shout over an equal raid shoutWarriorrecasts (wowsims)0.9 %Arms · Reck5 min, two warriors

    How to test

    1. Two level 60 warriors with the same top trainer Battle Shout rank.
    2. Warrior A shouts. Warrior B shouts while A's buff is up.
    3. Note B's result: refused with an error, a refresh, or B's buff replacing A's; and whether B spent rage and a GCD.
    Sims now
    The warrior's own Battle Shout recasts over the raid's equal-rank shout (wowsims engine; only its Protection rotation skips it).
    Alternative
    An equal shout is not recast (our old engine rule; no source).
    Sims right if
    B's shout goes off and refreshes (then skipping it is a rotation choice for the re-optimisation).
    Alternative right if
    B's shout is refused, no rage or GCD spent: the engine must not recast it.
    Impact
    No recast vs recast: Arms 3 bosses · 1 min +0.6..+0.9 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Effort
    5 min, two warriors
  34. 34Shank: procs and off-hand talentsRogueno procs, no off-hand talents (wowsims)1.5 %Combat20 min, solo (+ a respec or a second rogue)

    How to test

    1. Combat rogue, Instant Poison on the off hand only, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Macro /cast Shank + /stopattack; 100 Shanks with no white swings.
    3. Count poison procs at Shank's timestamps.
    4. Average non-crit Shank with Dual Wield Specialization 2/2, then 0/2 (respec, or a second rogue with the same off hand).
    Sims now
    Shank triggers no procs (row attributes; wowsims's own ruling waits for an in-game check) and takes no off-hand talents (Dual Wield Specialization, Hack and Slash's off-hand crit).
    Alternative
    Shank rolls off-hand poison, enchant and item procs and takes the off-hand talents (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    No procs, no change with DW Spec.
    Alternative right if
    Procs: Shank rolls procs. Higher with DW Spec: give Shank the talent.
    Impact
    wowsims's Shank vs ours: Combat −1.3..−1.5 % 1 boss · 1 min, −0.4..−1.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min; with DW Spec kept on Shank −0.5..−0.7 / −0.1..−0.7 %. Mutilate and Subtlety within ±0.4 %.
    Builds
    Combat
    Effort
    20 min, solo (+ a respec or a second rogue)
  35. 35Multi-Shot: whose Hunter's Mark each arrow readsHunterown target's mark (ours)1.1 %BM, MM, MM Lone Wolf, Survival weave15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter, /combatlog on, 3 dummies or mobs side by side.
    2. Mark target A. 30 Multi-Shots at A.
    3. Compare non-crit arrow damage on A with B and C.
    Sims now
    Each arrow reads its own target's Hunter's Mark (our patch; the mark's tooltip: 'against the target').
    Alternative
    Every arrow uses the primary target's ranged AP (wowsims).
    Sims right if
    B and C lower than A.
    Alternative right if
    All equal.
    Impact
    Own vs primary's: 3 bosses · 1 min BM −0.8..−0.9 %, MM −0.9..−1.1 %, Lone Wolf −1.1 %, SV weave −0.6..−0.8 %; 1 boss · 1 min 0.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  36. 36Raptor Strike queued on the walk-inHunterqueues on the walk-in (wowsims)≈1.0 %Survival weave10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 10 times: walk in from 10 yd pressing Raptor Strike before you reach melee range.
    3. Is the first melee hit Raptor Strike? Does pressing it out of range give an error?
    Sims now
    A Raptor Strike pressed on the walk-in queues and takes the first swing on arrival (wowsims).
    Alternative
    It only queues in melee range, so the rotation presses it on arrival (our old engine held the arrival swing for that).
    Sims right if
    It queues out of range; the first hit is Raptor Strike.
    Alternative right if
    Error out of range; the first hit is white.
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: under 1 % on the weaves.
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  37. 37Does the hunter pet take its owner's melee speed?Hunterinherits (wowsims)2.5 %BM, MM10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 hunter with a pet, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Pet auto-attacks 2 min: average time between pet white swings.
    3. Rapid Fire; the same from 5 s after the cast.
    Sims now
    Yes: owner's melee and attack speed (Rapid Fire, Wind Blessed, Berserking), never ranged haste, at the next pet heartbeat (wowsims #909: one level-36 log, 12 Rapid Fire changes).
    Alternative
    The pet takes none of its owner's speed (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    Pet swings ~40 % faster under Rapid Fire.
    Alternative right if
    No change.
    Impact
    Inherit vs none: BM +2.3..+2.5 % 1 boss · 1 min, +1.2..+2.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min; MM +0.7..+0.9 % (our engine).
    Builds
    BM, MM
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  38. 38Teebu's Blazing Longsword: Firebolt rateHunterRogueWarrior1 PPM (ours)1.1 %Survival melee, Fury DW · Reck, Combat, Hemo20 min, solo (needs the sword)

    How to test

    1. Anyone with Teebu's Blazing Longsword, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack 15 min.
    3. Count Firebolt procs; per minute = count ÷ 15.
    Sims now
    Firebolt (140 Fire) at 1 proc a minute (wowsims/classic rate; no Forever row states one).
    Alternative
    Any other rate.
    Sims right if
    About 1 a minute (15 ± 4).
    Alternative right if
    Clearly other: set it.
    Impact
    Proc on vs none: SV melee +1.0..+1.1 %, Fury +0.6..+0.9 %, Combat +0.6..+0.8 %, Subtlety +0.8..+0.9 %. Half weight: the strict pool drops Teebu's (no Wowhead source since 12 Nov) at the re-optimisation unless unsourced world drops stay.
    Effort
    20 min, solo (needs the sword)
  39. 39Does Stormstrike roll Windfury Totem?Shamanno roll (wowsims)≈1.0 %Enh15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Enhancement shaman, Rockbiter on the weapon, own Windfury Totem down, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. 100+ Stormstrikes over 10-15 min.
    3. Count WF Totem extra attacks at a Stormstrike's timestamp, and after white swings.
    Sims now
    No (wowsims #910: its row lacks the main-hand-required and next-swing bits; not logged).
    Alternative
    Yes, as a main-hand special (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    None off 100 Stormstrikes (white swings about 18 %).
    Alternative right if
    About the white-swing rate.
    Impact
    Not measured alone. #910's whole Windfury rule: Enhancement −1.8..−1.9 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.3..−1.5 % 3 bosses · 1 min; the Stormstrike share is unknown, estimated up to about 1 %.
    Builds
    Enh
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  40. 40Epic shields' block valuePaladinWarrior66 (ours, Wowhead)1.0 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Pala · Balanced2 min, solo (needs the shield or a link)

    How to test

    1. Anyone holding or seeing The Immovable Object (or another epic shield a saved tank wears).
    2. Read the block value on the tooltip; worn, compare Block on the character sheet with and without it.
    Sims now
    From Wowhead's Forever planner: The Immovable Object 66 (our patch).
    Alternative
    The client's TBC block table: 79 (wowsims).
    Sims right if
    66.
    Alternative right if
    79.
    Impact
    66 vs 79: prot warrior TPS −0.3..−0.4 %, balanced −0.6..−1.0 %, prot paladin balanced −0.4..−0.5 %.
    Effort
    2 min, solo (needs the shield or a link)
  41. 41Judgement as a ranged attack (11 Nov hotfix)Paladinranged (ours, Blizzard text)0.8 %Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat30-40 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Human paladin with a sword or mace, no hit gear, /combatlog on, a level 63 dummy (or the highest-level target you can hit).
    2. 200 Judgements of Righteousness.
    3. Count misses; count Crusader or Hand of Justice procs at a judgement's timestamp.
    Sims now
    Damaging judgements use the ranged hit table and trigger no melee procs (Blizzard 11 Nov hotfix, server-side, no row; our patch).
    Alternative
    Melee attacks with melee procs (both engines before the hotfix).
    Sims right if
    About 8 % misses and no item procs (ranged table, no racial weapon skill).
    Alternative right if
    About 6 % and item procs: still melee.
    Impact
    Ranged vs melee: Ret −0.4..−0.8 %, Shockadin −0.4..−0.7 %, prot −0.2..−0.5 %. Hit-capped sets see no miss change.
    Effort
    30-40 min, solo
  42. 42Unsealed Wrath Echoes after a main-hand swapPaladincleared (wowsims)0.9 %Ret10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Ret paladin with Unsealed Wrath and two main-hand weapons (e.g. Manual Crowd Pummeler), /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Build Echo stacks, swap the main hand, check the buff bar and the log.
    3. Repeat 10 times.
    Sims now
    A main-hand swap clears every stored Echo (wowsims #923: level 20-35 logs with no counts; the row gained EquipClass 2 in push 113772).
    Alternative
    Echoes survive the swap (our old engine; the Manual Crowd Pummeler swap kept them).
    Sims right if
    Echoes gone after every swap.
    Alternative right if
    Echoes stay.
    Impact
    Clear vs keep: Ret −0.42/−0.89 % 1 boss · 1 min, −0.26/−0.36 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Builds
    Ret
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  43. 43Sword Specialization off a Windfury Totem swingWarriorno proc (wowsims)≈1.0 %Arms · Reck (horde)30-40 min, needs a shaman

    How to test

    1. Horde Arms warrior, Sword Specialization 5/5, a sword, a shaman's Windfury Totem, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Auto-attack until you have 150+ Windfury Totem extra swings (about 30 min).
    3. Count Sword Specialization extra swings right after a WF swing, and after other hits.
    Sims now
    A Windfury Totem swing never brings a Sword Specialization extra swing (wowsims #897: 0 of 6 cases).
    Alternative
    WF Totem swings proc it like other hits (our old Classic carry-over).
    Sims right if
    None after 150 WF swings while other hits proc ~4 %.
    Alternative right if
    About the same rate after WF swings.
    Impact
    Not measured alone. wowsims's whole Sword Spec rule: Arms −0.6..−0.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, −2.1..−2.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min; the WF part moves horde Arms only, estimated −0.5..−1 %.
    Effort
    30-40 min, needs a shaman
  44. 44Cat finishers' attack power shares at the top ranksDruidwowsims's shares0.8 %Cat30 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 cat druid, top ranks, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
    2. 20 five-point Rips (read the ticks), 20 Rakes, 30 non-crit five-point Bites.
    3. Change AP by about 500 and repeat.
    4. Rise ÷ AP change for each.
    Sims now
    Rip 0.0114 × AP × min(CP, 4) a tick, Rake 0.065, Ferocious Bite 0.037 × AP a point (wowsims logs on ranks 1-4 at levels 22-51 with counts; ranks 5-6 extrapolated).
    Alternative
    Other values at the top ranks (our old placeholder: Rip 0.0125).
    Sims right if
    ≈ the shares above.
    Alternative right if
    Other values: set the top-rank shares.
    Impact
    wowsims's values vs ours: cat −0.7..−0.8 % (our engine).
    Builds
    Cat
    Effort
    30 min, solo
  45. 45Frostfire Bolt against Fire/Frost resistanceMagelowest resistance (ours)0.7 %Frostfire20 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Frostfire mage, /combatlog on, a target with Fire or Frost resistance (an elemental mob).
    2. 100+ Frostfire Bolts; count partial resists.
    3. The same number of Fireballs and Frostbolts on that target.
    Sims now
    Meets the lower of the target's Fire and Frost resistance, each school's own piercing (our patch; the tooltip; wowsims's own comment says 'least resistance').
    Alternative
    A mixed school with resistance 0 and piercing ignored (wowsims code).
    Sims right if
    FFB partials ≈ the less-resisted school's.
    Alternative right if
    FFB never partially resisted.
    Impact
    Our rule vs wowsims's: Frostfire +0.5/+0.7 % 1 boss · 1 min.
    Builds
    Frostfire
    Effort
    20 min, solo
  46. 46Hunter pet ability global cooldownHunter1.5 s (wowsims)≈0.5 %BM5 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Hunter with a pet at full Focus, /combatlog on, a dummy.
    2. Let the pet use its abilities 2 min with Focus never short.
    3. Average the gap between back-to-back pet ability casts.
    Sims now
    1.5 s (the row; wowsims).
    Alternative
    1.6 s: the row plus a 0.1 s pet AI delay (our old hand value).
    Sims right if
    1.5 s.
    Alternative right if
    About 1.6 s.
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: under 0.5 % on BM.
    Builds
    BM
    Effort
    5 min, solo
  47. 47Judgement of the Crusader on damage shieldsPaladinno bonus (wowsims)0.9 %Prot Pala · Threat15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 paladin with Retribution Aura, a mob that hits you, /combatlog on.
    2. Judge Seal of the Crusader on it; log 30+ Ret Aura hits with the judgement up and 30+ without.
    3. Compare the averages.
    Sims now
    Adds nothing to damage-shield hits (Retribution Aura, Thorns, item shields) (wowsims #872: 9/9 rank 1 Ret Aura hits at levels 1-19).
    Alternative
    Damage shields take the target's holy bonus (our old engine: Ret Aura 0.06 × the bonus).
    Sims right if
    Same average.
    Alternative right if
    Higher with the judgement up.
    Impact
    None vs bonus: prot paladin −0.42 % DPS / −0.44 % TPS 1 boss · 1 min, −0.82 / −0.88 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
    Effort
    15 min, solo
  48. 48Skyborne races' base statsall classes on High Order or Windshaperwowsims #881 sheets0.4 %builds at a Skyborne race (Balance, feral horde, Frost, Frostfire, Arcane alliance, High Order hunters)10 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Make a level 1 High Order and a level 1 Windshaper of one class, and one character of that class on another race.
    2. Remove all gear; read Str/Agi/Sta/Int/Spi.
    3. Skyborne offset = its stat − the other race's stat + that race's known offset.
    Sims now
    wowsims #881 level-1 sheets (6 Nov, none attached): High Order −3 Str/+4 Agi/−1 Sta/+4 Int/−3 Spi, Windshaper −4/+3/0/−1/+3.
    Alternative
    Our old −1/+1/−1/+1/0 for both (22 Sep beta sheets). Blizzard 2 Nov notes: corrected, no numbers.
    Sims right if
    −3/+4/−1/+4/−3 and −4/+3/0/−1/+3.
    Alternative right if
    Other values: put the read values in.
    Impact
    wowsims's offsets vs ours: −0.2..+0.37 % on builds at a Skyborne race (High Order hunters +0.25..+0.37 %, Windshaper melee −0.1..−0.2 %).
    Builds
    builds at a Skyborne race (Balance, feral horde, Frost, Frostfire, Arcane alliance, High Order hunters)
    Effort
    10 min, solo
  49. 49Threat from rage gains: scaled by stance or notWarriorunscaled (wowsims)≈0.6 %Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced, Fury/Prot15 min, solo

    How to test

    1. Level 60 prot warrior, Defensive Stance, Defiance, a mob that hits you. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
    2. Find 10+ Shield Specialization rage procs with nothing else in the same instant.
    3. Threat gained per proc.
    Sims now
    Rage from Shield Specialization, Master of Defense and Bloodrage's instant part makes 5 threat a rage, not scaled by stance or Defiance (wowsims #876/#882: level 6-24 logs, 8/8 clean windows, n 12).
    Alternative
    Scaled by the threat multiplier, ×2.16 in Defensive Stance with Defiance 3/3 (our old engine).
    Sims right if
    ≈ 25 per 5-rage proc.
    Alternative right if
    ≈ 54 (×2.16).
    Impact
    Not measured. Estimated: prot TPS −0.3..−0.6 % for the unscaled reading.
    Effort
    15 min, solo