In-game tests
Mechanics the sims assume but nobody has measured in game, largest estimated effect first: a result from any of them corrects the sims.
49 mechanics
1Maul threat multiplierDruid×1.75 (wowsims)Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced15 min (45 min with the other three bear tests), solo
How to test
- Level 60 druid in Dire Bear Form, top Maul rank, a training dummy or a mob that can't kill you. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
- Calibrate: 20 plain white hits with nothing else in the same instant. Threat gained ÷ damage = form multiplier F.
- Queue Maul on 20+ swings. Keep only non-crit Mauls with no other event in the same instant (no Enrage, no Primal Fury or other rage gain).
- Each Maul: threat gained ÷ (damage × F). Plot threat against damage: a line through zero means no flat part.
- Run the Swipe, Primal Bite and Lacerate tests in the same session.
- Sims now
- ×1.75 on Maul's damage. wowsims #822, a hand value: its PR says no game file states it.
- Alternative
- ×1, plain damage threat: our 25 Oct value. No measurement either.
- Sims right if
- Ratio ≈ 1.75.
- Alternative right if
- Ratio ≈ 1.0 (our 25 Oct value). Any other ratio, or a flat part: a new value to model.
- Impact
- ×1.75 vs ×1: bear TPS +30.4..+33.7 % 1 boss · 1 min, +30.7..+36.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine). Maul, Swipe and Primal Bite together at our values: −21.5..−22.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, −35.3..−37.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min TPS.
- Builds
- Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced
- Effort
- 15 min (45 min with the other three bear tests), solo
- Sources
2Swipe threat multiplierDruid×1.75 (wowsims)Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo (needs 2+ targets)
How to test
- Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test.
- Stand at 2-3 mobs or dummies. Swipe 20+ times with auto-attack stopped (a /stopattack macro).
- Read threat gained on your current target per Swipe and that target's Swipe damage; non-crits only.
- Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F).
- Sims now
- ×1.75 (wowsims #822, a hand value with no source).
- Alternative
- ×1 (our 7 Oct value; the Season of Discovery ×2 was dropped then). No measurement.
- Sims right if
- Ratio ≈ 1.75.
- Alternative right if
- Ratio ≈ 1.0.
- Impact
- ×1.75 vs ×1: bear TPS +17.6..+23.5 % 3 bosses · 1 min; 1 boss · 1 min 0 (no Swipe on one boss) (our engine).
- Builds
- Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced
- Effort
- 10 min, solo (needs 2+ targets)
- Sources
3Do melee swings keep landing while you channel Volley?Hunterswings continue (wowsims)Survival melee10 min, solo
How to test
- A hunter with a melee weapon, Volley trained, a training dummy. Turn on /combatlog.
- Stand in melee range and start auto attack. Let three or four swings land.
- Channel Volley on the dummy for its full 6 s, still in melee range. Don't move or cast anything else.
- In the log, count melee swings (SWING_DAMAGE, SWING_MISSED) between Volley's start and its aura fading.
- Repeat three times with a slow weapon and three times with a fast one.
- Sims now
- Yes. Only a spell with a cast time holds a melee swing; a channel holds none, so a hunter in melee range keeps swinging through Volley's 6 s (wowsims sim/core/attack.go, sim/hunter/volley.go). Survival (melee) channels Volley from 2 targets: on 3 bosses for 1 min it channels 54 of 60 s, and Volley is 55 % of its damage.
- Alternative
- No: the channel stops or pauses melee swings, as it stops Auto Shot. No measurement either way.
- Sims right if
- Swings land through the channel at the weapon's normal speed (about 6 s ÷ weapon speed each).
- Alternative right if
- No swings during the channel, or one held to its end: melee swings pause while channelling.
- Impact
- Melee swings and Raptor Strike landing during the channels: 17.5 % of Survival (melee)'s damage on 3 bosses · 1 min (one logged fight, 13 Nov; estimated). Survival (melee) is #2 on 3 bosses · 1 min at 1,890; without them about 1,560, sixth. 1 boss · 1 min 0 (no Volley on one boss).
- Builds
- Survival melee
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
4Is the 10 Nov Enhancement hotfix live?Shamannot live (client rows)Enh5-10 min, solo; re-check each week
How to test
- Any shaman with Stormstrike: read its tooltip (weapon damage %, cooldown) and time the cooldown once.
- Read the Mental Dexterity and Maelstrom Weapon talent tooltips at each rank.
- Windfury Weapon on the main hand and your own Windfury Totem down: hit a dummy 3 min with /combatlog on. Count procs of each (the log names both).
- Repeat after each weekly maintenance (next 17 Nov) until the values change.
- Sims now
- Pre-10 Nov values: Stormstrike 150 % weapon damage / 6 s cooldown, Mental Dexterity 50/100/150 % of Intellect as AP, Maelstrom Weapon 20 procs a minute at every rank and 4 % a stack per point, a main-hand Windfury Weapon replaces the party's Windfury Totem. Source: client rows of 12 Nov 06:16 UTC and player reports.
- Alternative
- Blizzard's 10 Nov hotfix list: Stormstrike 100 % / 8 s, Mental Dexterity 33/66/100 %, Maelstrom 20 % a stack at 6/7/8/9/10 procs a minute by rank, Windfury Weapon and Windfury Totem both proc.
- Sims right if
- 150 % / 6 s, old talent text, only the weapon's Windfury procs.
- Alternative right if
- 100 % / 8 s and the new text: model the block (the 71-line patch is measured). Both Windfury procs seen: drop the imbue-replaces-totem rule.
- Impact
- Stormstrike, Mental Dexterity and Maelstrom together: Enhancement −15.9/−16.2 % 1 boss · 1 min, −12.7/−13.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Pieces on our engine: Stormstrike −9.5..−9.8 %, Mental Dexterity −3.0..−3.1 %, Maelstrom −4.5..−4.6 % 1 boss · 1 min. Weapon + totem: 0 on saved sets (Rockbiter), a new candidate if live.
- Builds
- Enh
- Effort
- 5-10 min, solo; re-check each week
5Lacerate threat multiplier at level 60Druid×10/3 (wowsims)Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo
How to test
- Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test, top Lacerate rank.
- 20+ non-crit Lacerate hits on one target with auto-attack stopped, and 30+ ticks.
- Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F), for hits and for ticks separately.
- Note the stack count at each hit (the sim counts the stack the hit adds).
- Sims now
- ×10/3 on hit and ticks (wowsims #945 threat log: rank 2 in Bear Form firm, 33/40 hit and 59/65 tick windows; later ranks in Dire Bear fit only in part, 37/80 and 46/74 windows, none at ×1 or ×3).
- Alternative
- ×1 (our 7 Oct value).
- Sims right if
- ≈ 3.33 on hits and ticks at the top rank.
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 1.0. Any other value: model it.
- Impact
- ×10/3 vs ×1: bear TPS +42.8..+47.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..+2.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine).
- Builds
- Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
- Sources
6Primal Bite threat multiplierDruid×3 (wowsims)Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo
How to test
- Same setup and form multiplier F as the Maul test, top Primal Bite rank.
- 20+ non-crit Primal Bites with auto-attack stopped.
- Ratio = threat gained ÷ (damage × F); check for a flat part.
- Sims now
- ×3, no flat part (wowsims #822/#945: 'measured on the first two ranks', levels ~37-51, sample not published).
- Alternative
- ×2 (our 7 Oct value, from the 70170 note 'roughly doubled').
- Sims right if
- Ratio ≈ 3.
- Alternative right if
- Ratio ≈ 2.
- Impact
- ×3 vs ×2: bear TPS +12.3..+13.2 % 1 boss · 1 min, +8.4..+9.7 % 3 bosses · 1 min (our engine).
- Builds
- Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
7Chain Lightning overload chance per targetShamanfull chance (ours)Ele20 min, solo (needs 3 targets)
How to test
- Level 60 Elemental shaman, Lightning Overload at max rank, /combatlog on.
- One dummy: 100+ Lightning Bolts. Overloads ÷ casts = p.
- A group of 3+ mobs or dummies: 60+ Chain Lightnings that hit 3 targets (180+ target hits).
- Count overload copies per target hit (the log names the overload spell and its target).
- Sims now
- Full Lightning Overload chance on every target hit (our patch: the 408438 row and tooltip state one chance for both spells). No log.
- Alternative
- A third of the chance per target (wowsims code; its own PRs #821/#839 say no game file states it).
- Sims right if
- Overloads per target hit ≈ p.
- Alternative right if
- ≈ p/3. (180 target hits separate p from p/3 for any p above about 10 %.)
- Impact
- Full vs 1/3: Elemental 3 bosses · 1 min +12.0/+12.5 %, 1 boss · 1 min +0.7 %. Elemental is #1 on 3 bosses · 1 min (1,784); at 1/3 it falls behind Lone Wolf (estimated).
- Builds
- Ele
- Effort
- 20 min, solo (needs 3 targets)
8Revelation enchant: which hits roll itDruidMagePriestShamandamaging hits + channel ticks (wowsims)Frost, Balance, Ele, Shadow30 min, solo per class (a mage and a priest)
How to test
- Level 60 mage with Revelation on the weapon, /combatlog on, 3+ dummies or mobs.
- Channel Blizzard for 100+ ticks. Count Revelation procs on a tick with no direct cast landing.
- Priest (or warlock) with Revelation: 100+ Shadow Word: Pain (or Corruption) casts on fresh targets. Count procs at the application.
- The rate (9 vs 8.85 %) needs thousands of hits: skip it.
- Sims now
- wowsims's rules: only landed hits that deal damage or heal, plus each tick a channel casts (Blizzard, Hurricane, totems). Source: the row's Can Proc From Procs flag and the tooltip; no log. Rate 9 % (MythicSim's log count is 8.85 %).
- Alternative
- Our old rules: any landed non-crit spell hit or heal, zero-damage landings included (dot application, channel start), never a channel tick.
- Sims right if
- Procs on ~9 % of Blizzard ticks, none on dot applications.
- Alternative right if
- None on ticks, ~9 % on applications. A mix: model each part as seen.
- Impact
- wowsims's rules vs ours (our engine): Frost 3 bosses · 1 min +7.1/+6.8 %, Balance 3 bosses · 1 min +5.5/+5.9 %, Elemental 3 bosses · 1 min +1.3/+2.1 %, Shadow −2.9 % 1 boss · 1 min, −3.3 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Ticks alone: Frost 3 bosses · 1 min +10.7 %.
- Effort
- 30 min, solo per class (a mage and a priest)
9Holy Strike's spell power sharePaladin≈ 0.21 (wowsims)Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat, Prot Pala · Balanced20 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 paladin, Holy Strike Rank 8, no Judgement of the Crusader on the target, /combatlog on, a training dummy.
- 40+ non-crit Holy Strikes in normal gear; average them.
- Add about +100 spell power (an elixir or an item), nothing else; 40+ more.
- Rise in the average ÷ spell power added = the share.
- Sims now
- Spell power through the weapon percent: 0.429 × 50 % ≈ 0.21 at Rank 8 (wowsims, by analogy with the Seal of Command proc; no log).
- Alternative
- The row's full 0.429 coefficient (our old engine; no log).
- Sims right if
- Rise ≈ 21 per 100 spell power.
- Alternative right if
- Rise ≈ 43 per 100 spell power.
- Impact
- wowsims's reading vs ours (our engine): Ret −2.2..−3.1 %, Shockadin −2.2..−2.9 %, prot paladin DPS −1.4..−3.1 %, TPS −1.9..−4.2 %.
- Effort
- 20 min, solo
10Deep Wounds refresh: tick timerWarriorkeeps the timer (wowsims)Fury DW · Reck, Arms · Reck15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 warrior, Deep Wounds 3/3, high crit (Fury gear), /combatlog on, a training dummy.
- Attack 5 min. List every Deep Wounds application/refresh and every tick with its timestamp.
- Pick 30+ refreshes that land between two ticks.
- For each, measure the time from the refreshing crit to the next tick.
- Sims now
- A refresh keeps the first application's tick timer (wowsims; no evidence cited). Owner's call, 12 Nov 21:44.
- Alternative
- A refresh restarts the timer and the owed damage rolls into the new bleed (our rule of 7 Oct; our old engine).
- Sims right if
- Ticks keep their old rhythm through refreshes.
- Alternative right if
- The next tick comes one full tick interval after the refreshing crit, every time.
- Impact
- Reset vs keep: Fury −4.1..−4.3 % 1 boss · 1 min, −3.3..−3.4 % 3 bosses · 1 min; Arms −1.1..−1.4 % (the reset is 47 of wowsims's 63 Deep Wounds DPS).
- Builds
- Fury DW · Reck, Arms · Reck
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
11Vindication and Demoralizing Shout/Roar: stack or notDruidPaladinWarriorone category (wowsims)Prot Pala · Mitigation, Prot Pala · Balanced, Prot Pala · Threat30 min, 2-3 players
How to test
- A paladin with Vindication, a warrior with Demoralizing Shout (or a druid with Demoralizing Roar), a tank, a level 60 elite that hits the tank. /combatlog on.
- Phase A: Shout only. Phase B: Vindication only. Phase C: both. 100+ mob hits on the tank in each.
- In each phase, check the mob's debuff bar: do both show?
- Average the mob's normal hits (no crush, no block) per phase.
- Sims now
- Vindication shares Demoralizing Shout/Roar's category: only the stronger applies (wowsims 7a79ab991; no in-game check).
- Alternative
- Its own aura, both apply (our old engine; the 19 Oct test PAL-8 is still open).
- Sims right if
- Phase C = the stronger of A and B.
- Alternative right if
- Phase C lower than both A and B.
- Impact
- wowsims's reading vs ours: mitigation/balanced paladin DTPS +4.7 % 1 boss · 1 min, +1.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min; prot_paladin 3 bosses · 1 min +0.9 %. Survival scores move by about the DTPS change (estimated).
- Effort
- 30 min, 2-3 players
12Gnomish Battle Chicken: how often it squawksDruidHunterPaladinRogueShamanWarriorevery summon (MythicSim, ours)Arms · Reck, Fury DW · Reck, Bear (3 variants), Ret, Shockadin, Enh, Combat, Mutilate, Hemo, Survival melee, Cat, Prot Warr (3 variants)1 min a summon, but a 30 min cooldown: 10-20 summons over a week, solo or pooled
How to test
- An engineer with Gnomish Battle Chicken, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Summon it in combat each time the 30 min cooldown is up. Note whether Battle Squawk appears (buff and log line).
- Once: note the buff's size (melee speed on the character sheet) and duration.
- Pool summons from several engineers.
- Sims now
- Battle Squawk (+5 % melee speed, 4 min) on every summon (MythicSim's reading). The buff itself is the client row (SpellEffect 699978).
- Alternative
- About one summon in two (Classic player reports; no Forever count).
- Sims right if
- Every summon squawks (10 of 10).
- Alternative right if
- Any summon without a squawk rules out 'always'; the share over 20+ summons is the rate to model.
- Impact
- Chicken on vs off: Arms +2.7..+3.8 %, Fury +3.4..+3.5 %, bears +3.1..+3.6 %, Ret 0..+5.3 %, Shockadin +2.6 %, rogues +1.6..+2.3 %, SV melee +2.3..+2.8 %, Enhancement +2.5 %, feral +1.8..+2.0 %, prot warriors +1.2..+2.1 %. A 50 % squawk halves each (estimated).
- Builds
- Arms · Reck, Fury DW · Reck, Bear (3 variants), Ret, Shockadin, Enh, Combat, Mutilate, Hemo, Survival melee, Cat, Prot Warr (3 variants)
- Effort
- 1 min a summon, but a 30 min cooldown: 10-20 summons over a week, solo or pooled
13Is Hurricane sped up by haste?Druidhasted (wowsims)Balance15 min, solo (needs a haste source)
How to test
- Balance druid, top Hurricane rank, /combatlog on, a group of dummies or mobs.
- 5 full Hurricanes with no haste: note the time between ticks and the tick count.
- 5 more under a cast-speed effect (haste rating gear, a haste trinket or buff).
- Compare tick spacing and channel length.
- Sims now
- Yes (wowsims; no source).
- Alternative
- No (forever-bugs #437, a tester report).
- Sims right if
- Ticks come faster under haste.
- Alternative right if
- Same spacing: reinstate the unhasted patch.
- Impact
- Unhasted vs hasted: Balance 3 bosses · 1 min −2.6/−3.6 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
- Builds
- Balance
- Effort
- 15 min, solo (needs a haste source)
- Sources
- forever-bugs #437
14Talisman of Ascendance: ends after 6 spells?DruidMagePaladinPriestShamanWarlock6 spells (ours, item text)caster and healer builds wearing it (82 requests), Prot Pala · Threat5 min, solo (needs the trinket)
How to test
- A caster with Talisman of Ascendance, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Use it; cast fast spells and count them until the buff fades (the log's 'fades' line).
- Do it 3 times; once with slow casts so 20 s comes first.
- Sims now
- Ends after the 6th damage or healing spell or 20 s (our patch, from the item text 'Expires after 6 damage or healing spells or 20 seconds').
- Alternative
- Runs the full 20 s (wowsims: the row's ProcCharges is 0).
- Sims right if
- It fades on the 6th spell.
- Alternative right if
- It lasts 20 s whatever you cast.
- Impact
- 6-spell end vs 20 s: casters −1.3..−3.6 %, prot paladin TPS −1.5..−2.0 %, healers −0.5..−3.6 %. By build, wowsims's reading on our engine: Arcane +3.3..+3.5, Destruction +3.4..+3.7, Elemental +2.6..+3.9 %.
- Builds
- caster and healer builds wearing it (82 requests), Prot Pala · Threat
- Effort
- 5 min, solo (needs the trinket)
15Low-rank spell power penalty at level 60DruidPaladinPriestour fitted formulaSmite, Holy Pala · Party, Holy Priest · Party, Resto Druid · Party10 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 priest. Read the tooltip damage of Smite rank 6 (max level 43), rank 4 and the top rank.
- Add about +100 spell power (item or elixir); read the three tooltips again.
- If a tooltip is unclear, 20 non-crit casts of that rank at each spell power level.
- Share kept = rank's rise ÷ the top rank's rise (same 2.5 s cast).
- Sims now
- Share = 1 − 0.05 × (60 − the rank's max level − 12), floored at 0 (Blizzard 1 Oct and 2 Nov notes say low ranks lose spell power, with no formula; this one is our fit to tooltips at levels 18-30).
- Alternative
- Another formula at 60, or none (wowsims's base has no penalty).
- Sims right if
- Rank 6 keeps about 75 %, rank 4 none.
- Alternative right if
- Other values: refit the formula at 60.
- Impact
- Penalty vs none: Smite −1.5..−4.0 %, Holy paladin party −1.1..−1.6 %, Holy priest party 0..−0.7 %, resto druid party −0.4 %. Most of Smite's part is a rank-2 fallback the re-optimisation should drop.
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
16Deadly Poison: attack power per tick or per applicationRogueper application (wowsims)Combat, Mutilate, Hemo15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 rogue, Deadly Poison (trainer rank IV) on a weapon, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
- Build 5 stacks; read 10 ticks.
- Change AP by about 300 (an AP item or buff), let the stacks fall off, rebuild 5, read 10 ticks.
- Tick change ÷ (5 stacks × AP change).
- Sims now
- 0.009 × AP a stack spread over 4 ticks, 0.00225 a tick (wowsims, 'Confirmed by Zirene', no log).
- Alternative
- 0.009 × AP a stack on every tick (our old patch; one beta log, report 2701, ~363 AP, rank 1).
- Sims right if
- ≈ 0.00225 (300 AP, 5 stacks: +3.4 a tick).
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 0.009 (+13.5 a tick).
- Impact
- Per tick vs spread: Combat +0.7..+1.0 %, Mutilate +2.3..+2.5 %, Subtlety +2.0..+2.3 %.
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
17Does the Mutilate cast itself roll on-hit effects?Roguecast rolls (wowsims)Mutilate15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 Mutilate rogue, Instant Poison on the main hand only, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- 100+ Mutilates; ignore white swings (match by timestamp).
- Count main-hand Instant Poison procs at each Mutilate's timestamp, and Mutilates with two procs.
- Sims now
- Yes: the cast rolls main-hand procs besides its two strikes (wowsims; its own TODO 'double MH poison proc'; no log).
- Alternative
- Only the two hand strikes roll (our old patch; no log).
- Sims right if
- About twice the poison's chance a Mutilate, some with two procs.
- Alternative right if
- About the chance once, never two.
- Impact
- Strikes only vs cast too: Mutilate −2.6..−2.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, −2.6 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
- Builds
- Mutilate
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
18Level-based partial resists on a level 63 bossDruidMagePriestShamanWarlocknone (both engines)every caster DPS buildOne raid night of logs, needs a raid
How to test
- Needs a level 63 boss (raids open 9 Dec).
- Any caster, /combatlog on, a school the boss doesn't resist.
- Log 300+ landed spell hits (normal raid play is enough).
- Count partial resists (a resisted amount on a hit).
- Sims now
- None (both engines; wowsims's logs show none at +2 levels, 49,488 hits). Nobody has logged +3.
- Alternative
- Classic-style level-based partial resists at +3.
- Sims right if
- No, or almost no, partial resists.
- Alternative right if
- Regular 25/50/75 % partials: model level-based resists.
- Impact
- Not measured this round. The 3 Nov review put the lift from dropping level-based partial resists at up to 6-9 % for casters; the same swing back (estimated).
- Builds
- every caster DPS build
- Effort
- One raid night of logs, needs a raid
19Shield Slam Rank 4 flat threatWarrior267 (wowsims)Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 prot warrior, Shield Slam Rank 4, Defensive Stance, a training dummy or a mob you can tank. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
- Calibrate: threat ÷ damage on 20 white hits = stance multiplier M.
- 15+ non-crit Shield Slams with nothing else in the same instant; 5+ crits.
- Flat part = (threat gained − damage × M) ÷ M.
- Sims now
- 267, added once on a crit (wowsims: Rank 1 measured at 177.7, levels 40-42, n 28 and 16; Ranks 2-4 carried by spell level, never measured).
- Alternative
- 508 (our old Classic ×2 carry-over, no Forever source), or nearer Rank 1's 178.
- Sims right if
- ≈ 267.
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 508, or ≈ 178: set that value.
- Impact
- 508 vs 267: prot warrior TPS +3.3 %, balanced +3.9 % 1 boss · 1 min; +2.6 %, +2.9..+3.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min. 178 vs 508: −4.4..−6.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, so about −1..−2 % against 267 (estimated).
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
20Fiery Weapon (and Lifestealing) proc rateHunter6 PPM (ours)Survival melee15 min, solo
How to test
- Any melee with Enchant Weapon - Fiery Weapon, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note weapon speed.
- Auto-attack 10 min (no extra-attack effects).
- Count Fiery Weapon hits; per minute = count ÷ 10.
- Optional: another weapon speed (per minute or per hit).
- Sims now
- Fiery Weapon 6 procs a minute, Lifestealing 6.66 (Classic rates; no Forever row states one; wowsims gives both no effect).
- Alternative
- Another rate (no source).
- Sims right if
- About 6 a minute (60 ± 8 in 10 min).
- Alternative right if
- Clearly other: set the rate.
- Impact
- Fiery Weapon on vs off: SV melee +1.9..+2.1 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..+1.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min. Lifestealing is not worn.
- Builds
- Survival melee
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
21Eviscerate attack power per combo pointRogue0.04 (wowsims)Combat, Mutilate, Hemo20 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 rogue, top Eviscerate rank, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
- 30+ non-crit 5-point Eviscerates.
- Change AP by about 500 (buffs, elixirs or AP items); 30+ more.
- Rise in the average ÷ (5 × AP change).
- Sims now
- 0.04 × AP a point (wowsims, 'estimated from in-game tests', no log shown).
- Alternative
- 0.03 × AP a point (our old reading; no log).
- Sims right if
- ≈ 0.04 (500 AP: +100 a hit).
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 0.03 (+75 a hit).
- Impact
- 0.04 vs 0.03: Combat +0.9..+1.0 %, Mutilate +1.6..+1.7 %, Subtlety +0.5..+0.6 % (our engine).
- Effort
- 20 min, solo
22Soulforge 4-piece: Crusader's Wrath ratePaladin3 PPM (ours)Prot Pala · Threat, Ret20 min, solo (needs the set)
How to test
- Paladin in 4 original Soulforge pieces, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note weapon speed.
- Auto-attack (with your normal rotation) 15 min.
- Count Crusader's Wrath procs; per minute = count ÷ minutes.
- Optional: repeat with a weapon of another speed (per minute or per hit).
- Sims now
- 3 procs a minute (our engine's literal; no row or text states a rate; wowsims models none).
- Alternative
- Any other rate (no source).
- Sims right if
- About 3 a minute (45 ± 7 in 15 min).
- Alternative right if
- Clearly other: set the rate.
- Impact
- Proc on vs none: prot paladin TPS +1.3..+1.8 %, Ret 3 bosses · 1 min +1.8 % (alliance). Scales with the rate.
- Builds
- Prot Pala · Threat, Ret
- Effort
- 20 min, solo (needs the set)
23Ice Lance spell power coefficientMage1/7 (wowsims)Frost15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 Frost mage, top Ice Lance rank, /combatlog on, a dummy that is not frozen.
- 30+ non-crit Ice Lances at normal spell power.
- Add 200+ frost spell power; 30+ more.
- Rise ÷ spell power added.
- Sims now
- 1/7 ≈ 0.143 (wowsims, a TBC carry-over with its own 'until measured' TODO).
- Alternative
- 0.10 (our old value from two level-26 beta logs, 84 hits at ~80 spell power).
- Sims right if
- ≈ 0.143.
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 0.10.
- Impact
- 0.10 vs 1/7: Frost −1.4 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.7 % 3 bosses · 1 min; 1/7 on our engine +1.3/+1.9 %.
- Builds
- Frost
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
24Do Flamestrike's tick crits light Ignite?Mageticks ignite (ours)Fire, Frostfire15 min, solo
How to test
- Fire mage with Ignite, /combatlog on, 2-3 dummies.
- 20+ Flamestrikes. Find tick crits with no other crit within 2 s.
- Check whether an Ignite application or refresh follows each.
- Sims now
- Yes (our patch; Blizzard 2 Nov notes: Ignite now applies past Flamestrike's first hit; tick crits seen in foreverlogs 2668).
- Alternative
- Only the first hit's crits (wowsims: its Ignite trigger hears direct hits only).
- Sims right if
- Ignite follows tick crits.
- Alternative right if
- Never.
- Impact
- Tick Ignite vs none: Fire 3 bosses · 1 min +5.05/+5.11 %, Frostfire +4.90/+4.09 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
25Thunder Clap attack power share at the top rankWarrior0.07 (wowsims)Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced20 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 warrior, top Thunder Clap rank, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- 30+ non-crit Thunder Claps at normal AP.
- Change AP by about 500; 30+ more.
- Rise ÷ AP change.
- Sims now
- 0.07 × AP (wowsims #931, measured on Ranks 1 and 4 at levels 43-45; no sample size given).
- Alternative
- 0.0255 × AP (our old fit, 61 rank 1 hits at level 20).
- Sims right if
- ≈ 0.07.
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 0.026. Another value at the top rank: set it.
- Impact
- 0.07 vs 0.0255: prot TPS 1 boss · 1 min +0.3 % (mitigation +1.3..+1.4 %), 3 bosses · 1 min +2.4..+2.9 %; DPS 3 bosses · 1 min +3.0..+4.4 % (our engine).
- Effort
- 20 min, solo
- Sources
26Immolation Trap attack power shareHunter10 % of RAP (wowsims)Survival melee, Survival weave20 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 hunter, top Immolation Trap rank, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note melee AP, ranged AP and Clever Traps rank.
- 5 traps; sum each trap's ticks.
- Raise ranged AP only by ~300 (a ranged-AP item); 5 more traps.
- Raise melee AP only by ~300 (a melee-AP item or buff); 5 more traps.
- Sims now
- 10 % of ranged AP over the ticks (wowsims, 'the Forever notes'; no number in the 15 Oct or 2 Nov text).
- Alternative
- 13.2 % of the higher of melee and ranged AP (forever-bugs #283, a combat-log fit with Clever Traps 2/2).
- Sims right if
- Total rises ≈ 0.10 × ranged AP added, not with melee AP.
- Alternative right if
- Rises ≈ 0.132 × whichever AP is higher.
- Impact
- 13.2 % vs 10 %: SV melee +0.7 % 1 boss · 1 min. 10 % on our engine: SV melee −0.6 / −1.3..−1.4 %, SV weave −0.4 / −0.9..−1.0 %, BM/MM 1 boss · 1 min −0.2..−0.3 %.
- Builds
- Survival melee, Survival weave
- Effort
- 20 min, solo
- Sources
- forever-bugs #283
27Shieldsworn: does Holy Strike roll Reckoning?Paladinno Reckoning (wowsims)Prot Pala · Threat, Prot Pala · Balanced10 min, solo
How to test
- Prot paladin, Shieldsworn and Reckoning 5/5, a shield, Holy Shield off, /combatlog on.
- A dummy that doesn't attack; Holy Strike only, 50+ times.
- Count Reckoning charges or extra attacks.
- Sims now
- No: Holy Strike activates Holy Shield and Shield Specialization only (wowsims; the live Wowhead tooltip of 1328544 names just these two).
- Alternative
- Also Reckoning (our old engine; 2 Nov notes: 'all talents that activate when you block').
- Sims right if
- None in 50+.
- Alternative right if
- Any Reckoning charge.
- Impact
- wowsims's reading vs ours: prot DPS −1.7..−3.2 %, TPS −1.2..−2.5 %.
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
28Lacerating Strikes refresh: replace or roll overHunterreplaces (ours)Survival melee, Survival weave10 min, solo
How to test
- SV hunter with Lacerating Strikes, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Refresh the bleed 20+ times before it runs out.
- Compare the tick size right before and right after each refresh.
- Sims now
- A refresh replaces the bleed on a fresh timer, no rollover (our rule + Blizzard notes 'always overwrites'; our patch).
- Alternative
- The remaining damage rolls into the new bleed (wowsims).
- Sims right if
- Same tick size after a refresh.
- Alternative right if
- Bigger ticks after a refresh.
- Impact
- Replace vs rollover: SV melee −1.9..−2.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.5..−1.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min; SV weave −0.9..−1.0 / −0.6..−0.7 %.
- Builds
- Survival melee, Survival weave
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
29Windfury Totem swings and Unsealed Wrath Echoes (11 Nov hotfix)Paladinno Echo (ours, Blizzard text)Ret15 min, needs a shaman
How to test
- Ret paladin with Unsealed Wrath, a shaman's Windfury Totem, a seal up, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Auto-attack; check Echo stacks (buff bar or log) right after each WF Totem proc.
- Get 30+ WF procs.
- Sims now
- A WF Totem extra attack stores and spends no Echo (Blizzard 11 Nov hotfix, server-side, no row; our patch).
- Alternative
- WF swings store Echoes (both engines before the hotfix; true if the hotfix isn't live as written).
- Sims right if
- No stack after any WF proc.
- Alternative right if
- Stacks after WF procs: drop the patch.
- Impact
- No Echo vs Echo: Ret −1.9..−2.0 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.2..−1.3 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
- Builds
- Ret
- Effort
- 15 min, needs a shaman
- Sources
30Auto Shot's 0.5 s stand-still: does haste shorten it?Hunterhasted wind-up (wowsims)Survival weave, BM20 min, solo
How to test
- Hunter with a swing-timer addon, screen recording at 60 fps, a dummy.
- 20 times: move, stop; count frames from the stop to the Auto Shot release.
- 20 more under Rapid Fire (or another ranged haste).
- Sims now
- Yes: a 0.5 s wind-up shortened by ranged haste (wowsims #733, from sim scenarios).
- Alternative
- 0.5 s after the last move, unhasted (our old engine; Blizzard 15 Oct notes give the 0.5 s, 'matching Classic').
- Sims right if
- Shorter under haste.
- Alternative right if
- Still 0.5 s.
- Impact
- Not measured. Estimated: under 1 % on the weave builds.
- Builds
- Survival weave, BM
- Effort
- 20 min, solo
- Sources
31Rage decay before the pullDruidWarriordecays (ours)Fury DW · Reck, Bear · Threat, Bear · Balanced10 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 warrior out of combat with a rage readout (a /run print(UnitPower('player')) macro, or the bar).
- Bloodrage out of combat: note whether you enter combat (combat icon); read rage each second for 5 s.
- Same with Berserker Rage (and a druid's Enrage), then pull a dummy and note rage at the pull.
- Repeat with Anger Management if you have it.
- Sims now
- Rage decays 1.25 a second out of combat (client PowerType Rage RegenPeace −12.5), 30 % less with Anger Management, never below the starting rage; a pre-pull Bloodrage or Berserker Rage partly decays (our patch).
- Alternative
- No pre-pull decay (wowsims's base), e.g. if those effects put you in combat.
- Sims right if
- Rage falls ~1.25 a second right after the effect, out of combat.
- Alternative right if
- Rage holds until the pull.
- Impact
- Decay vs none: Fury −0.5..−0.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, 0..−1.1 % 3 bosses · 1 min; bears −0.5..−1.5 % TPS 1 boss · 1 min, −0.2..−0.9 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
32Dungeon set 2 four-piece procs: Warrior's Resolve, Rogue Armor EnergizeRogueWarrior1 PPM (ours)Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Warr · Mitigation, rogues in Darkmantle20 min per set, solo (needs the set)
How to test
- Warrior in 4 original Battlegear of Heroism pieces (or a rogue in 4 Darkmantle), /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Auto-attack 15 min.
- Count Warrior's Resolve (or Rogue Armor Energize) procs; per minute = count ÷ 15.
- Sims now
- 1 proc a minute each (our engine's literals; the rows state no rate; wowsims models none).
- Alternative
- Any other rate (no source).
- Sims right if
- About 1 a minute (15 ± 4).
- Alternative right if
- Clearly other: set the rate.
- Impact
- Heroism 4pc (Warrior's Resolve) on vs off, our old engine: prot warrior balanced/mitigation TPS −0.2..−1.1 %. Rogue Armor Energize not measured. Worn active bonuses on 1 boss · 1 min + 3 bosses · 1 min: Heroism 16, Darkmantle 5.
- Builds
- Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Warr · Mitigation, rogues in Darkmantle
- Effort
- 20 min per set, solo (needs the set)
33Battle Shout over an equal raid shoutWarriorrecasts (wowsims)Arms · Reck5 min, two warriors
How to test
- Two level 60 warriors with the same top trainer Battle Shout rank.
- Warrior A shouts. Warrior B shouts while A's buff is up.
- Note B's result: refused with an error, a refresh, or B's buff replacing A's; and whether B spent rage and a GCD.
- Sims now
- The warrior's own Battle Shout recasts over the raid's equal-rank shout (wowsims engine; only its Protection rotation skips it).
- Alternative
- An equal shout is not recast (our old engine rule; no source).
- Sims right if
- B's shout goes off and refreshes (then skipping it is a rotation choice for the re-optimisation).
- Alternative right if
- B's shout is refused, no rage or GCD spent: the engine must not recast it.
- Impact
- No recast vs recast: Arms 3 bosses · 1 min +0.6..+0.9 %, 1 boss · 1 min 0.
- Builds
- Arms · Reck
- Effort
- 5 min, two warriors
34Shank: procs and off-hand talentsRogueno procs, no off-hand talents (wowsims)Combat20 min, solo (+ a respec or a second rogue)
How to test
- Combat rogue, Instant Poison on the off hand only, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Macro /cast Shank + /stopattack; 100 Shanks with no white swings.
- Count poison procs at Shank's timestamps.
- Average non-crit Shank with Dual Wield Specialization 2/2, then 0/2 (respec, or a second rogue with the same off hand).
- Sims now
- Shank triggers no procs (row attributes; wowsims's own ruling waits for an in-game check) and takes no off-hand talents (Dual Wield Specialization, Hack and Slash's off-hand crit).
- Alternative
- Shank rolls off-hand poison, enchant and item procs and takes the off-hand talents (our old engine).
- Sims right if
- No procs, no change with DW Spec.
- Alternative right if
- Procs: Shank rolls procs. Higher with DW Spec: give Shank the talent.
- Impact
- wowsims's Shank vs ours: Combat −1.3..−1.5 % 1 boss · 1 min, −0.4..−1.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min; with DW Spec kept on Shank −0.5..−0.7 / −0.1..−0.7 %. Mutilate and Subtlety within ±0.4 %.
- Builds
- Combat
- Effort
- 20 min, solo (+ a respec or a second rogue)
35Multi-Shot: whose Hunter's Mark each arrow readsHunterown target's mark (ours)BM, MM, MM Lone Wolf, Survival weave15 min, solo
How to test
- Hunter, /combatlog on, 3 dummies or mobs side by side.
- Mark target A. 30 Multi-Shots at A.
- Compare non-crit arrow damage on A with B and C.
- Sims now
- Each arrow reads its own target's Hunter's Mark (our patch; the mark's tooltip: 'against the target').
- Alternative
- Every arrow uses the primary target's ranged AP (wowsims).
- Sims right if
- B and C lower than A.
- Alternative right if
- All equal.
- Impact
- Own vs primary's: 3 bosses · 1 min BM −0.8..−0.9 %, MM −0.9..−1.1 %, Lone Wolf −1.1 %, SV weave −0.6..−0.8 %; 1 boss · 1 min 0.
- Builds
- BM, MM, MM Lone Wolf, Survival weave
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
36Raptor Strike queued on the walk-inHunterqueues on the walk-in (wowsims)Survival weave10 min, solo
How to test
- Hunter, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- 10 times: walk in from 10 yd pressing Raptor Strike before you reach melee range.
- Is the first melee hit Raptor Strike? Does pressing it out of range give an error?
- Sims now
- A Raptor Strike pressed on the walk-in queues and takes the first swing on arrival (wowsims).
- Alternative
- It only queues in melee range, so the rotation presses it on arrival (our old engine held the arrival swing for that).
- Sims right if
- It queues out of range; the first hit is Raptor Strike.
- Alternative right if
- Error out of range; the first hit is white.
- Impact
- Not measured. Estimated: under 1 % on the weaves.
- Builds
- Survival weave
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
37Does the hunter pet take its owner's melee speed?Hunterinherits (wowsims)BM, MM10 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 hunter with a pet, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Pet auto-attacks 2 min: average time between pet white swings.
- Rapid Fire; the same from 5 s after the cast.
- Sims now
- Yes: owner's melee and attack speed (Rapid Fire, Wind Blessed, Berserking), never ranged haste, at the next pet heartbeat (wowsims #909: one level-36 log, 12 Rapid Fire changes).
- Alternative
- The pet takes none of its owner's speed (our old engine).
- Sims right if
- Pet swings ~40 % faster under Rapid Fire.
- Alternative right if
- No change.
- Impact
- Inherit vs none: BM +2.3..+2.5 % 1 boss · 1 min, +1.2..+2.0 % 3 bosses · 1 min; MM +0.7..+0.9 % (our engine).
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
- Sources
38Teebu's Blazing Longsword: Firebolt rateHunterRogueWarrior1 PPM (ours)Survival melee, Fury DW · Reck, Combat, Hemo20 min, solo (needs the sword)
How to test
- Anyone with Teebu's Blazing Longsword, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Auto-attack 15 min.
- Count Firebolt procs; per minute = count ÷ 15.
- Sims now
- Firebolt (140 Fire) at 1 proc a minute (wowsims/classic rate; no Forever row states one).
- Alternative
- Any other rate.
- Sims right if
- About 1 a minute (15 ± 4).
- Alternative right if
- Clearly other: set it.
- Impact
- Proc on vs none: SV melee +1.0..+1.1 %, Fury +0.6..+0.9 %, Combat +0.6..+0.8 %, Subtlety +0.8..+0.9 %. Half weight: the strict pool drops Teebu's (no Wowhead source since 12 Nov) at the re-optimisation unless unsourced world drops stay.
- Builds
- Survival melee, Fury DW · Reck, Combat, Hemo
- Effort
- 20 min, solo (needs the sword)
39Does Stormstrike roll Windfury Totem?Shamanno roll (wowsims)Enh15 min, solo
How to test
- Enhancement shaman, Rockbiter on the weapon, own Windfury Totem down, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- 100+ Stormstrikes over 10-15 min.
- Count WF Totem extra attacks at a Stormstrike's timestamp, and after white swings.
- Sims now
- No (wowsims #910: its row lacks the main-hand-required and next-swing bits; not logged).
- Alternative
- Yes, as a main-hand special (our old engine).
- Sims right if
- None off 100 Stormstrikes (white swings about 18 %).
- Alternative right if
- About the white-swing rate.
- Impact
- Not measured alone. #910's whole Windfury rule: Enhancement −1.8..−1.9 % 1 boss · 1 min, −1.3..−1.5 % 3 bosses · 1 min; the Stormstrike share is unknown, estimated up to about 1 %.
- Builds
- Enh
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
- Sources
40Epic shields' block valuePaladinWarrior66 (ours, Wowhead)Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced, Prot Pala · Balanced2 min, solo (needs the shield or a link)
How to test
- Anyone holding or seeing The Immovable Object (or another epic shield a saved tank wears).
- Read the block value on the tooltip; worn, compare Block on the character sheet with and without it.
- Sims now
- From Wowhead's Forever planner: The Immovable Object 66 (our patch).
- Alternative
- The client's TBC block table: 79 (wowsims).
- Sims right if
- 66.
- Alternative right if
- 79.
- Impact
- 66 vs 79: prot warrior TPS −0.3..−0.4 %, balanced −0.6..−1.0 %, prot paladin balanced −0.4..−0.5 %.
- Effort
- 2 min, solo (needs the shield or a link)
41Judgement as a ranged attack (11 Nov hotfix)Paladinranged (ours, Blizzard text)Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat30-40 min, solo
How to test
- Human paladin with a sword or mace, no hit gear, /combatlog on, a level 63 dummy (or the highest-level target you can hit).
- 200 Judgements of Righteousness.
- Count misses; count Crusader or Hand of Justice procs at a judgement's timestamp.
- Sims now
- Damaging judgements use the ranged hit table and trigger no melee procs (Blizzard 11 Nov hotfix, server-side, no row; our patch).
- Alternative
- Melee attacks with melee procs (both engines before the hotfix).
- Sims right if
- About 8 % misses and no item procs (ranged table, no racial weapon skill).
- Alternative right if
- About 6 % and item procs: still melee.
- Impact
- Ranged vs melee: Ret −0.4..−0.8 %, Shockadin −0.4..−0.7 %, prot −0.2..−0.5 %. Hit-capped sets see no miss change.
- Builds
- Ret, Shockadin, Prot Pala · Threat
- Effort
- 30-40 min, solo
- Sources
42Unsealed Wrath Echoes after a main-hand swapPaladincleared (wowsims)Ret10 min, solo
How to test
- Ret paladin with Unsealed Wrath and two main-hand weapons (e.g. Manual Crowd Pummeler), /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Build Echo stacks, swap the main hand, check the buff bar and the log.
- Repeat 10 times.
- Sims now
- A main-hand swap clears every stored Echo (wowsims #923: level 20-35 logs with no counts; the row gained EquipClass 2 in push 113772).
- Alternative
- Echoes survive the swap (our old engine; the Manual Crowd Pummeler swap kept them).
- Sims right if
- Echoes gone after every swap.
- Alternative right if
- Echoes stay.
- Impact
- Clear vs keep: Ret −0.42/−0.89 % 1 boss · 1 min, −0.26/−0.36 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
- Builds
- Ret
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
- Sources
43Sword Specialization off a Windfury Totem swingWarriorno proc (wowsims)Arms · Reck (horde)30-40 min, needs a shaman
How to test
- Horde Arms warrior, Sword Specialization 5/5, a sword, a shaman's Windfury Totem, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Auto-attack until you have 150+ Windfury Totem extra swings (about 30 min).
- Count Sword Specialization extra swings right after a WF swing, and after other hits.
- Sims now
- A Windfury Totem swing never brings a Sword Specialization extra swing (wowsims #897: 0 of 6 cases).
- Alternative
- WF Totem swings proc it like other hits (our old Classic carry-over).
- Sims right if
- None after 150 WF swings while other hits proc ~4 %.
- Alternative right if
- About the same rate after WF swings.
- Impact
- Not measured alone. wowsims's whole Sword Spec rule: Arms −0.6..−0.8 % 1 boss · 1 min, −2.1..−2.8 % 3 bosses · 1 min; the WF part moves horde Arms only, estimated −0.5..−1 %.
- Builds
- Arms · Reck (horde)
- Effort
- 30-40 min, needs a shaman
- Sources
44Cat finishers' attack power shares at the top ranksDruidwowsims's sharesCat30 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 cat druid, top ranks, /combatlog on, a dummy. Note AP.
- 20 five-point Rips (read the ticks), 20 Rakes, 30 non-crit five-point Bites.
- Change AP by about 500 and repeat.
- Rise ÷ AP change for each.
- Sims now
- Rip 0.0114 × AP × min(CP, 4) a tick, Rake 0.065, Ferocious Bite 0.037 × AP a point (wowsims logs on ranks 1-4 at levels 22-51 with counts; ranks 5-6 extrapolated).
- Alternative
- Other values at the top ranks (our old placeholder: Rip 0.0125).
- Sims right if
- ≈ the shares above.
- Alternative right if
- Other values: set the top-rank shares.
- Impact
- wowsims's values vs ours: cat −0.7..−0.8 % (our engine).
- Builds
- Cat
- Effort
- 30 min, solo
45Frostfire Bolt against Fire/Frost resistanceMagelowest resistance (ours)Frostfire20 min, solo
How to test
- Frostfire mage, /combatlog on, a target with Fire or Frost resistance (an elemental mob).
- 100+ Frostfire Bolts; count partial resists.
- The same number of Fireballs and Frostbolts on that target.
- Sims now
- Meets the lower of the target's Fire and Frost resistance, each school's own piercing (our patch; the tooltip; wowsims's own comment says 'least resistance').
- Alternative
- A mixed school with resistance 0 and piercing ignored (wowsims code).
- Sims right if
- FFB partials ≈ the less-resisted school's.
- Alternative right if
- FFB never partially resisted.
- Impact
- Our rule vs wowsims's: Frostfire +0.5/+0.7 % 1 boss · 1 min.
- Builds
- Frostfire
- Effort
- 20 min, solo
46Hunter pet ability global cooldownHunter1.5 s (wowsims)BM5 min, solo
How to test
- Hunter with a pet at full Focus, /combatlog on, a dummy.
- Let the pet use its abilities 2 min with Focus never short.
- Average the gap between back-to-back pet ability casts.
- Sims now
- 1.5 s (the row; wowsims).
- Alternative
- 1.6 s: the row plus a 0.1 s pet AI delay (our old hand value).
- Sims right if
- 1.5 s.
- Alternative right if
- About 1.6 s.
- Impact
- Not measured. Estimated: under 0.5 % on BM.
- Builds
- BM
- Effort
- 5 min, solo
47Judgement of the Crusader on damage shieldsPaladinno bonus (wowsims)Prot Pala · Threat15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 paladin with Retribution Aura, a mob that hits you, /combatlog on.
- Judge Seal of the Crusader on it; log 30+ Ret Aura hits with the judgement up and 30+ without.
- Compare the averages.
- Sims now
- Adds nothing to damage-shield hits (Retribution Aura, Thorns, item shields) (wowsims #872: 9/9 rank 1 Ret Aura hits at levels 1-19).
- Alternative
- Damage shields take the target's holy bonus (our old engine: Ret Aura 0.06 × the bonus).
- Sims right if
- Same average.
- Alternative right if
- Higher with the judgement up.
- Impact
- None vs bonus: prot paladin −0.42 % DPS / −0.44 % TPS 1 boss · 1 min, −0.82 / −0.88 % 3 bosses · 1 min.
- Builds
- Prot Pala · Threat
- Effort
- 15 min, solo
- Sources
48Skyborne races' base statsall classes on High Order or Windshaperwowsims #881 sheetsbuilds at a Skyborne race (Balance, feral horde, Frost, Frostfire, Arcane alliance, High Order hunters)10 min, solo
How to test
- Make a level 1 High Order and a level 1 Windshaper of one class, and one character of that class on another race.
- Remove all gear; read Str/Agi/Sta/Int/Spi.
- Skyborne offset = its stat − the other race's stat + that race's known offset.
- Sims now
- wowsims #881 level-1 sheets (6 Nov, none attached): High Order −3 Str/+4 Agi/−1 Sta/+4 Int/−3 Spi, Windshaper −4/+3/0/−1/+3.
- Alternative
- Our old −1/+1/−1/+1/0 for both (22 Sep beta sheets). Blizzard 2 Nov notes: corrected, no numbers.
- Sims right if
- −3/+4/−1/+4/−3 and −4/+3/0/−1/+3.
- Alternative right if
- Other values: put the read values in.
- Impact
- wowsims's offsets vs ours: −0.2..+0.37 % on builds at a Skyborne race (High Order hunters +0.25..+0.37 %, Windshaper melee −0.1..−0.2 %).
- Builds
- builds at a Skyborne race (Balance, feral horde, Frost, Frostfire, Arcane alliance, High Order hunters)
- Effort
- 10 min, solo
- Sources
49Threat from rage gains: scaled by stance or notWarriorunscaled (wowsims)Prot Warr · Threat, Prot Warr · Balanced, Fury/Prot15 min, solo
How to test
- Level 60 prot warrior, Defensive Stance, Defiance, a mob that hits you. Turn on /combatlog and a raw-threat logger (wowsims testers used ThreatLog; a threat meter that shows raw threat also works).
- Find 10+ Shield Specialization rage procs with nothing else in the same instant.
- Threat gained per proc.
- Sims now
- Rage from Shield Specialization, Master of Defense and Bloodrage's instant part makes 5 threat a rage, not scaled by stance or Defiance (wowsims #876/#882: level 6-24 logs, 8/8 clean windows, n 12).
- Alternative
- Scaled by the threat multiplier, ×2.16 in Defensive Stance with Defiance 3/3 (our old engine).
- Sims right if
- ≈ 25 per 5-rage proc.
- Alternative right if
- ≈ 54 (×2.16).
- Impact
- Not measured. Estimated: prot TPS −0.3..−0.6 % for the unscaled reading.
- Effort
- 15 min, solo