What one number means
A level's number is its cycle: the time from one kill to the next. It adds the fight, the meal and drink before you pull again, the few yards of walking, looting, and deaths weighted by a 120 s penalty each (D7). Half of a level's experience is counted as kills of mobs that level (D6). Multiply each level's kills by its cycle, add 10 through 59, and you have the score a path is ranked by; the guide shows the differences between paths and levels as percentages.
Behind each cell are 1,000 runs of 12 counted pulls, each run opened by three pulls that are not counted. So a cycle never starts fresh. You come into a pull with whatever health, mana, shield charges and standing totems the previous one left.
The mob, and how often there are two
- The test mob is a same-level melee creature (class 1) that faces you, so your swings can be parried or blocked. It hits for the min-to-max melee damage listed in the 1.12 database, plus its attack power. Its health is the 1.12 table's for its class and level, at Forever's factor of 1.0 (D1).
- Pulls are 80 % one mob and 20 % two mobs, with only your own buffs (D2). By kills that makes one in three a double. A caster and a mob two levels down appear as sensitivities on the Rotation page.
- Distances follow D9: mobs 25 yd apart, pulled from 30 yd, running at 7 yd/s, then 2 s to loot. The cycle times no mount and no Ghost Wolf travel.
The shaman in the sim
- Rockbiter is the imbue throughout, a fixed attack power bonus in Forever that
Elemental Weapons and
Spirit Weapons raise. Windfury and Flametongue were tried and were slower. - Stormstrike strikes from 5 yd at most, every 6 s, for 150 % of the weapon's normalised damage.
Flurry runs 6–30 %, and
Mental Dexterity converts 50/100/150 % of Intellect to attack power. All three use the 2 Nov notes' values, not the older figures still in the client's rows. - Lightning Shield loses a charge whenever a mob's attack lands on you, and that charge's orb strikes the attacker. The three charges and the 3.5 s gap between orbs are the client row's.
- Totems. The sim treats the Searing Totem's attacks as damage tied to the mob you dropped it for, so a fresh one goes down each pull. Strength of Earth and the water totems last their full time, and nothing checks a totem's range. A totem still standing after a fight covers the next one, which D9 places a few yards away.
Totemic Recall refunds a quarter of the mana of whatever totems stand. - Heals. Healing Wave and Lesser Healing Wave are ordinary casts, and a hit taken mid-cast pushes them back. When to heal in combat is one of the thresholds the search tries.
- Left out: weapon skill on a new weapon type, Purge, kiting with Frost Shock or Earthbind, Reincarnation, mobs running away, and dungeons.
Gear and food
- Your default gear is the quest track (D3), chosen anew at each level from quest rewards (dungeon quest rewards among them), vendor weapons, and suffixed greens whose item level is at most two above yours. No enchants. A reward from a faction's own zones, from Ragefire Chasm or from the Stockade only goes to that faction; class quest rewards only to the class.
- Quest rewards count from the quest's required level, so a quest far above your level may need a group or a few more levels first. A reward whose quest has no required level on file counts from the item's own.
- A quest with a choice of rewards gives one for good: the path keeps the one that helps most over the climb. Battleground rewards are left out.
- The Gear page measures each item on top of that set, as how much faster it makes your kills, from the level you can equip it.
- The search used Alliance gear on a Dwarf. The path was also run on Horde gear on an Orc: 3–11 % faster at 11–17, within about 2 % at 18–29 and 44–59, and 1–7 % slower at 30–43.
- Food and drink are the best your level can buy. First Aid is taken as skill 5 per level, to 300 (D4).
Talents and respecs
- Legality is the live client's tree (owner decision O1). It puts Improved Ghost Wolf in the fourth row, behind 15 Enhancement points; orders that take it sooner are left out.
- The search walks the checkpoints by itself and also tries a few fixed starting orders. One puts every point before 25 in the first three Enhancement rows and Stormstrike at 25; that start is the path shown.
- The order is in whole talents: at each step every talent left is measured with all its remaining ranks, and the biggest gain per point takes them all. A filler gets only the points that open the next row.
- Respec prices are D5's guesses (owner decision O3): the first reset 1 g, each later one 5 g dearer to a 50 g cap, and five minutes of travel valued at the band's gold per hour. Dual spec at 40 is taken as 10 g. No shaman path respecs.
What moved the verdict
Over the climb the tree was never close, though Restoration leads by up to 4 % at 21–23. Stormstrike decides it: removing it makes a kill about 30 % longer at 25 and 30–50 % longer from 30. Mob damage set the thresholds: with the database's hits, eating to 90 % was best at every level.
Limits, and what nobody has checked in game
- Both corpses of a two-mob pull share one 2 s loot, while D9 allows 2 s each. Every class reads about 2 % fast for it, and no verdict changes.
- The calibration in docs/leveling/CALIBRATION.md (owner decision O2) is still to be done in game. These numbers come from the 1.12 data, not from Forever's servers. Not yet calibrated: mob melee damage, mob health (raised past 30 on 3 Nov by an unpublished amount), health and mana regeneration ticks, food, and the orbs' damage.
- Zone routes, AoE farming, PvP, dungeons and Legacy perks are outside the model (D11). The engine is WoWSims Forever, extended below 60; the project's leveling bench does the search and the measuring.